The FeiThink Library · Standalone

My View on the Huawei 251 Incident

3 min

Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.

This is not going to be a long piece.
I am just curious how many people understand that the Huawei 251 incident and the Hong Kong question are essentially one and the same.
Only when the iron fist comes down on people in the same situation can there be resonance; that people cannot make even the slightest extension of the thought, what short-sightedness.

I see people on WeChat Moments still looking at the issue only from the angle of Huawei’s corporate management, and I think to myself, could we have a little more elevation.
No matter how much it protests that it is a private company, that cannot conceal the fact that Huawei itself is part of the state machine.
Huawei can mobilize such instruments of state power as the police, procuratorate, and courts to go after an individual; why does this kind of thing happen again and again?
Why do so many people still aim their spearheads solely at the corporate level, that most peripheral of branches?

Does no one seriously think about how to solve the problem at its root?
Looking through the historical records, present-day Chinese society is also a typical case in which class contradiction outweighs national contradiction.
The rise of totalitarianism is a grave threat to the broad ordinary masses, far worse than the imperialist ambition to destroy us.
How many real cases like 251 will it take for this to become mainstream understanding?
That people do not dare to speak out because of fear is one thing; but when the voices that do come out only evade the contradiction and shift the focus, such voices would be better left unvoiced.

Of course someone has proposed a fundamental solution; the person who proposed it won an award, got cancer, and it has now been two years.
If we want a fundamental solution, there is no way but true rule of law.
If we want true rule of law:
First, legislation must be fair, which also requires equality and democracy with one person, one vote;
Second, the judiciary must be independent, which also requires that public instruments be used for public ends, nationalization of the military, and separation of fiscal and administrative power;
Third, there must be freedom of speech to provide feedback.
Lately I keep scrolling past people arguing the defects of democracy, but fortunately no one has yet dispensed with the rule of law altogether.
Do you think I do not know the defects? Is it not still a helpless choice of the lesser of two evils?
If ordinary people could even experience those defects, they should count themselves lucky; that would already count as sweet sorrow.

Another thing that makes me sigh is that today, when the fruits of technological research are put into application so quickly, how hard it is to put the fruits of social science, advanced forms of social organization, into application.
The power of vested-interest groups and human stupidity both leave one helpless.
Then again, how do we know it is not a blessing?
Model training needs data; the growth of human intelligence needs lessons.
Suffering can make people awaken faster.

The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Next: On the Drive System and Modes of Thought

If this stayed with you, write to me

New volumes arrive here

Email RSS

My View on the Huawei 251 Incident
The FeiThink Library
First published 2019.12.03

Fei Huang · Writes from Amsterdam on Kant, Dostoevsky, and the moral life.