The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Thoughts Occasioned by the Pandemic

3 min

Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.

Natural disasters are not frightening at all. What is always most infuriating is the man-made calamity.

In these troubled times, I feel that expressing sympathy now is both useless and cheap.
Apart from showing that I have sympathy and follow trending topics, it does no real damned good.
I want to look at things from my own perspective and offer some different lines of thought.

Through this pandemic, it can be clearly seen that social governance is a specialized technical profession. Only the capable are fit to occupy it.
The epidemic prevention situations in Henan and Hubei can be glimpsed from the credentials of the officials in charge.
The governor of Henan and the mayor of Zhengzhou come from Shanghai and Hangzhou; the Hubei party secretary comes from the Northeast. It is indeed as Shi Nianyi said: select cadres more from places with clean politics, not from provinces of office-seekers or provinces of bureaucratism; they can benefit a locality.

The more important lesson: is this kind of bureaucrat a once-in-a-decades occurrence?
Just as I saw on Weibo a moment ago, someone said that in ‘03 the Beijing mayor was Wang Qishan, a once-in-a-decade one.
No. One can see that officials who come out of those service-oriented governments with clean politics are, with high probability, more capable of governance than sycophants.
In other words, technocrats with the capacity for social governance can be mass-produced.

And are the social and economic benefits brought by such officials any less than those brought by entrepreneurs, scientists, and engineers?
Think of the consequences of a city of ten million like Wuhan being locked down for a long time.
Organizational management is also a productive force.
To hold office for one term and benefit a locality should not be merely some political ideal of a peaceful and orderly world; it should be something real, clear, executable, and measurable.

But why does the phenomenon today show the entire bureaucratic system increasingly taking on the ways of the Northeast rather than those of Jiangsu and Zhejiang?
I have no clear answer.
I think it is related to the regression of the rule of law into rule by law.
When those above have a liking, those below will go further. If those above like to use selective anti-corruption to decide officials’ careers, anyone with eyes knows that the standard for anti-corruption depends more on factional alignment than on performance. Such a mechanism obviously rewards political officials rather than service-oriented officials.
If ten years ago we attacked the GDP-only doctrine, the current selection system is clearly inferior: it is a regression of the system. For that one at least had clear standards and a relatively transparent process.

A sudden fancy struck me: what if all the local government officials in every place resigned collectively, and then people in each place paid out of their own pockets to choose people to govern them?
Would officials produced here in Jiangsu, Zhejiang, and Shanghai be bought out of stock, like the Shaoxing shiye (private advisors of old Shaoxing)?
Or is it that local customs and conditions differ, so the direction would differ too? For example, people in the Northeast would have to spend money on a big brother, or else they could not keep the place under control; Tibetan compatriots would have to spend money on a great lama…
Would it eventually converge? For example, Uyghur brothers first spend money on a great imam, then find that it does not work and cannot fill their bellies, and in the end still have to separate church and state: the spiritual to the great imam, the secular to the Shaoxing shiye.

Having listed all this, I suddenly realize that I never imagined a place that would actively spend money to hire sycophants like Li Hongzhong.
Then again, who the hell would spend their own money to support idle people. The room for this kind of official to exist probably lies only in a political system of top-down appointment.

If things were really done this way, would they surely be governed better than the status quo? Would there be any unexpected hidden dangers?

An open question: I have no answer.

I would quite like to see that day.

The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Next: On Habit Formation and Domains

If this stayed with you, write to me

New volumes arrive here

Email RSS

Thoughts Occasioned by the Pandemic
The FeiThink Library
First published 2020.01.25

Fei Huang · Writes from Amsterdam on Kant, Dostoevsky, and the moral life.