The FeiThink Library · Standalone
A Simple Patriotic Function
13 min
Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.
A classmate commented with some different opinions on my last article.
I write this article in reply. I will not repeat the original comment under the public account article Inspired by Matthew Pottinger.
I have reached a rough conclusion from discussions of the Hong Kong issue and do not wish to start another dispute.
But I will still record my thoughts to sort out my thinking and perhaps offer others some insight.
Once this is written, it is finished. Unless there are useful additions, I will not open this topic again in the short term.
I. What Do We Mean When We Talk About Patriotism
Long-term binding patriotic education makes it hard to tell what exactly patriotism loves. Country, territory, people, culture, government… we examine them one by one.
The closest answer is the country: a larger community that gives people a sense of belonging.
I understand the concept of a group. But this criterion of classification is questionable, because it divides people not by individual choice but by bloodline, ethnic group, and birthplace. If I am born in the United States I must love the United States; if I am born in North Korea I must love North Korea. That is ridiculous.
Shouldn’t we first look at just what kind of thing it is we love?
And the country is an abstract concept; in the end it still has to land on the following concrete points.
- Territory
The so-called magnificent rivers and mountains of the motherland are, in the end, dead things. This should be the least important point in patriotism.
- People
This is also a neutral term. There is no problem with loving those hardworking, brave, and kind people, but are there not also so many people who cheat you, deceive you, and bully you?
Innate differences between ethnic groups really exist, but they are far less significant than the influence of acquired culture.
- Culture
I think this is the key. Soft things are what win people’s hearts.
At present I take a negative attitude toward Chinese culture.
If the real world were a game of Civilization, I would not hesitate to replace its cultural policy. The lack of the rule of law and the spirit of contract raises the cost of market allocation of resources; a society of personal connections opens a back door for rent-seeking by power; disordered worship of money undermines public order and good morals; patriotic education deprives people of judgment between right and wrong and delays the process of a healthy civil society. All these raise the overall operating costs of society and obstruct society from entering a more ordered and efficient state.
- Government
What matters is the institutions and policies behind it. Institutions and policies can change culture; the Peng Yu case in Nanjing shows a glimpse.
My question is: if Matthew Pottinger (newly appointed U.S. deputy national security adviser), mentioned in my last article, had his patriotism ignited by being beaten by state security in China while investigating corruption and nuclear proliferation, then what expression should we who are inside wear when we encounter similar things?
II. A Crude Objective Function
@Shan, in the comments under my last article I suggested that you use a function or model in discussing this with me.
Here is my current rough and crude version.
- Objective Function
From the standpoint of a patriot, the goal should be to maximize the national interest: Max(P).
P stands for the national interest. The national interest is the sum of all individual interests I: P=Sigma(I).
I stands for individual interest, shaped by ideology; for example, mainlanders value economic interests more than other things and prefer order to freedom. Different values have different weights.
(The following is made up off the top of my head; additions welcome.)
I=f(F, R, S, C, L, E…)
| Symbol | Meaning | Reference indicators |
|---|---|---|
| F Finance | Economic interest | Economic growth rate Per capita income |
| R Rights | Freedoms and rights | Rule of law index Press freedom index |
| S Security | Order and security | National defense military power Crime rate |
| C Cost | Cost of living | Consumer price index Per capita consumption expenditure Pension, education, and medical expenditure Quality & cost of public services |
| L Living | Quality of life | Average life expectancy Environmental conditions |
| E Education | Education and innovation | Average years of schooling Scientific and technological R&D Cultural output Degree of social civility |
- Rough Mechanism
The people authorize a party to form a government, make policy, and reallocate resources so as to maximize the national interest.
The government allocates resources in two ways:
First, it obtains fiscal revenue through taxation and allocates directly through the use of that fiscal revenue;
Second, it guides the market through policy and allocates indirectly.
Generally, society gives feedback on policy through the press and speech. Democratic societies also have impeachment and elections; nondemocratic countries have coups.
My main doubts about the current mechanism are:
1. Representation and Authorization
First, representation is insufficient. For example, with the vast peasant population, it is hard to think of anyone who has put forward a proposal truly representing their interests;
Second, if something goes wrong, you can neither give feedback through the legitimate channel of a free press, nor is there an electoral system by which to replace or impeach it.
Earlier, a widely circulated speech by Li Shimo from six years ago, Xianggang xuesheng kanle, jiu hui zhudong huijia, circulated on WeChat Moments. Many things in it, such as ‘an authoritarianism responsive to public opinion,’ have ceased to work in recent years, and then you find that, apart from its conscience awakening, society has no way to correct it.
In the wugu zhi huo (witchcraft calamity), Emperor Wu of Han did not wake up until half the people in Chang’an had died.
2. Taxation and Public Finance
At present, besides direct taxation, there is also covert taxation through excessive money issuance and inflation.
Earlier I did not understand how the 4 trillion accelerated the polarization between rich and poor. Later I figured it out: the government covertly taxes the people through excessive money issuance, just like the zhibai large coin that Liu Bei minted, and then completes a secondary distribution of wealth by subcontracting projects to a bureau director’s brother-in-law and the like.
The problem reflected is that there is no effective oversight over the collection and use of fiscal budgets.
3. The Policy-Making and Decision-Making Process
At present rules and policies can be made arbitrarily without constraint. I think there is a serious ‘principal-agent problem.’ That is, the interests of a small group are placed before the overall interests of society. Some policies that from society’s perspective have no positive significance at all can be reasonably explained from the perspective of a small group. There are too many; I will not list them.
My doubts about the actual situation are:
1. The Wealth Gap
Many people see others’ problems clearly but cannot see the same problems in themselves. Many attribute the Hong Kong problem to economic causes, to the wealth gap in Hong Kong society. I do not agree, but even following that logic you will find something absurd: the wealth gap in the mainland is even worse than in Hong Kong. Hong Kong’s Gini coefficient is 0.54, while according to a report by Southwestern University of Finance and Economics the mainland’s is above 0.6.
Under such real conditions, I have classmates who still advocate state capitalism; I absolutely cannot agree with this. The problem with wealth polarization is that it causes social wealth to settle, slows circulation, leaves those with real needs lacking purchasing power, and in the long run suppresses the healthy development of the economy.
2. Freedom or Order
Yesterday I saw someone say, ‘The belief that China will inevitably democratize is the greatest illusion of the late 20th century. No one likes corruption and abuse of power, but Chinese people fear chaos and are not yet ready to have other options. As long as it still says it serves the people, the authorities will have supporters.’
I deeply agree. As for whether the famous claim by that foreigner Franklin, ‘Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety,’ applies to Chinese people, that remains to be verified. We shall see.
III. Answers to Readers’ Questions
@Shan, next let us analyze the problems you raised one by one.
1. On Dialectics
I am not questioning Hegel’s dialectic; I am questioning your dialectic. I have seen too many people use dialectic to paper things over. Tell me, what meaning does a sentence like ‘No system is perfect’ have? Apart from denying the existence of problems and dissolving efforts at improvement, what meaning does it have?
2. On Economic Achievements
The achievement of leading the world’s largest group out of poverty is undeniable.
But as for how to attribute it, this question is too complex, far from as unquestionable as you imagine.
(1) All those countries that originally had very low starting points, the Four Asian Tigers, once experienced rapid development.
What does this show? That their systems were most suitable?
No, it only proves the importance of openness and integration into the world market.
In more detail, we can also analyze one by one which of the policies of our Party-state over the past 40 years have been positive and which negative.
Speaking only of economic policy (social policy is too complex and harder to explain clearly):
Positives: Sino-U.S. relations, the market economy, the tax-sharing system (doubtful), joining the WTO, a stable and peaceful environment, GDP competition among cities, the low human-rights advantage…
Negatives: the 4 trillion, the state advances while the private sector retreats, P2P financial innovation, supply-side reform, destocking, deterioration of Sino-U.S. relations…
The causes of economic development can be summarized mainly as:
a. Openness. Because China maintained good diplomatic relations with the United States, it was incorporated into the world trading system and opened up world markets;
b. Market. Allowing the market to allocate resources freely, with the government not interfering too much;
c. Peace, stability, and no disruptive campaigns.
In any field where the government (at city level and above) actively intervenes, problems mostly outweigh achievements. The only exception I can think of, one of the few, is high-speed rail.
(2) Past achievements that everyone can see cannot prove the correctness of future policies.
More importantly, past experience has gradually ceased to be valid. The favorable international environment is already in the past; this has factors of accumulated contradictions and also human factors. There has already been a major shift in policy direction.
If you truly affirm past achievements, are you not at the same time expressing dissatisfaction with the present? Or are you merely blindly believing that ‘the old man is always right.’
3. On Poverty Alleviation
Do you know the standard for the poverty line?
2300 yuan, a year, 6.3 yuan a day on average.
Do you know how that number you just cited should properly be read?
It means that at least 82 million people in China, 6% of the population, have an annual income barely above 2300 yuan.
You can also work out how cheap it would be to lift 82 million people out of poverty. 188.6 billion yuan, 27 billion dollars, and that still assumes these people had not one cent of income to begin with.
For comparison, do you know how lavishly the Belt and Road scatters money? 60 billion dollars, just like that.
Plug that into the objective function we were just discussing and explain to me why scattering it abroad matters more and yields more than scattering it at home? Writing this, the only lines I can think of are two from Du Mu’s Epang Palace Rhapsody: ‘Why must they take it all in scruples and grains, only to spend it like mud and sand.’ Money put into diplomacy of course brings diplomatic returns; I only think someone should be watching and keeping the accounts straight, holding the purse strings tight the way the U.S. Congress does.
4. On Investigative Journalists and Academic Freedom
When I speak of investigative journalists, what I am essentially talking about is society’s healthy feedback mechanism.
Ten years ago there was still investigative reporting like the Sanlu story; now it has essentially died out. Even when it happens occasionally, it never reaches your eyes. Does that mean social development has no problems left? A problem does not cease to exist because you decline to expose it. The right way is to air it, not let it rot.
On academic freedom, the example you gave is a very poor one; it is like using the West’s ban on pedophilia to justify internet censorship.
A difference of orders of magnitude in quantity is a difference in kind. When ordinary research and ordinary speech are both affected, then it is no longer the case that everywhere is the same.
As for whether Germany really forbids even scholarly research on the Nazis, I think you are making it up, but I have no evidence.
5. On the Cost of the Celebration
Doesn’t that strike you as a problem in itself? A celebration this big, and can you now say how much it actually cost? Even a company has to have its financial statements audited. With no oversight, no regulation, no audit, and you tell me he will spend the money in the way that is best for the people, are you insulting my intelligence or theirs?
The point of the question is not whether there should be a celebration but that there should be a broadly representative and independent parliament guarding the public purse and scrutinizing the budgets and spending of government departments.
6. On the Improvement of Social Affairs
First, you are only in a first-tier city. Do you know anything about the second, third, fourth, fifth… Nth tier? It is good that you see these improvements in the first tier, but you also have to see that plenty of places are in fact going the way of the Northeast.
Second, this belongs to administration, not to politics. It is a basic public service function the government ought to perform.
Third, some improvement does not say anything about the efficiency of resource use. Look at it another way: if you took the resources going into these public service departments and put them out for open bidding, handed them to the market, would you believe me that it would cost less and be done better? Look at Xuexi Qiangguo, which Alibaba was commissioned to build, then look at 12306, which the government built back then.
7. On the ‘Final’ Part
Is pointing out problems meaningless? Criticism is also part of building.
The Shuimu forum these days is a foul fog, unreadable. Now that the voices of opposition have vanished, some fellows, because no one opposes them, mistake themselves for men holding the truth. The more I understand the importance of a voice of opposition. Is it not the collision of the two sides that makes the argument clearer the longer it is argued?
As for the state, I do not have a paternal complex; I would rather look at this from the angle of an old friend, the way I put it to my sister:
If you had a friend you played with since childhood, and he has now gone down a crooked road, joined the underworld say, what would you do?
My sister said she would do her best to talk him out of it.
And if he will not listen? Not only will not listen, but treats you as the villain. You know he will certainly be schooled by society eventually, broken bones, prison, or maybe one day he becomes the boss himself. What do you do?
In the end it seems you can only keep your distance and leave him to be tested by society.
The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Next: Inspired by Matthew PottingerIf this stayed with you, write to me
The FeiThink Library
First published 2019.10.04