The FeiThink Library · Standalone
On IQ Snobbery and Arrogance
11 min
Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.
After I finished the last essay, Qiang Ge questioned my use of IQ as a criterion of judgment.
There is indeed that problem.
But this matter has troubled me many times. I cannot pretend it does not exist, nor console myself by saying I do not care.
In fact, IQ is not the capital we are proud of; it is more often a weapon for fighting back.
A weapon for fighting back against other people’s intrusions.
I call it “defensive arrogance”.
I. Notes on a Q&A with Qiang Ge: On IQ Discrimination
Qiang asked: (Fighting back against what?) For example?
I said: For example, the people who tell me to get out of China. I need to be certain that I stand on higher ground.
Qiang asked: If a dog bites you, how do you prove to the dog that you are superior?
I said: How do you know the other person is a dog? Take the two of us arguing about Hong Kong, for example.
Qiang Ge gave an example: a very impressive Tsinghua senior was loudly showing off to his girlfriend in public and was despised by Zhang Qing’s close friend. He sighed that the so-called successful people we desperately admire are actually worthless to people who have nothing to do with them. He said he felt his goal was wrong, if what a person seeks is other people’s approval.
I said I would simply ignore that close friend, if I happened to share the same goal as the big shot.
Qiang asked: What is your life’s value?
I said:
I want to know the world. To use the Tsinghua school song: “capacity and discernment first, letters and arts follow.”
The approval of ordinary people already means nothing to me, like XL’s wife or Zhang Qing’s close friend.
I already expressed this truthfully in the essay What I Want to Do.
a great mind.
Qiang asked: Then why do you still care?
I said:
So I do not care at all how much money Wang San’er makes, but I cannot be indifferent to what he says in the fields that interest me. Because he does not belong to the category of dogs you just mentioned. Even if his views are very far from mine, I cannot deny that he has a point.
I need to distinguish right from wrong, or who occupies the probabilistic advantage of possibly being correct.
In the social sciences, verifying a view is extremely difficult. Sometimes you really can only rely on these extraneous factors to make a rough inference.
And this is also an important characteristic attribute. Once you have met enough people, you find that a person’s level of cognition and their views and positions are largely determined by IQ and education.
II. Notes on an Analysis of a Blocking: On the Boundary Between the Individual and the Collective
I then sighed that, because of L’s wife, it would be hard for L and me to become friends.
The points on which L’s wife offended me were such that, while I was playing a game, following L’s lead, I half-jokingly called her SB and was blocked:
- She morally judged me. She asked why I was going to Germany right before Chinese New Year, and I said it was exactly to avoid the New Year pressure to marry.
Although she did not say it aloud, one look was enough to know that in her heart she classified me as an unfilial person.
I can understand that your father is in poor health, but do you have to silently judge me and accuse me of this and that? - She dares to talk glibly about things she half understands.
- She has no judgment and no discernment.
When we were playing Zha Jin Hua, she judged a not very impressive strategy of Fan’s as impressive, treating Zha Jin Hua as a game of bluffing people. - She thinks her stock trading is on the same level as mine. Although I am not that advanced yet, and may not compare to L.
But she pulled me down to her level, and I still felt humiliated. - After L got together with her, he constantly reinforced idiotic views, which made me feel that L’s IQ had dropped.
Even though I had already ranked them by importance, Qiang Ge still insistently attributed the main reason to her having offended my high-IQ persona. He told me I needed to change this, saying that most people think they are very smart.
Let me gripe here: look how arrogant people are. They never seriously listen to what you say; they only follow their own imaginations. And my persona is not high IQ; my persona is truth-seeking. High IQ is only the observation I make of my current state, as close to reality as possible. If one day my brain goes bad, I will still try as hard as I can to be an idiot who tells the truth.
Actually, moral judgment is the most important problem.
I understand that she is a girl who is filial to her parents under a traditional education. But no matter how filial you are, that is your own business. You do not understand how much trouble other people have suffered because of parent-child relationships.
After I left the state-owned enterprise and before I turned thirty, the most painful thing every year was going home for Chinese New Year. My parents and relatives took turns pressing me to marry and showing meticulous concern for my career, mixed with my own frustration at not having become a successful person in other people’s eyes. All of this made Chinese New Year the most painful time of my year, and it even took me a long time after the holiday to recover.
In 2016, in Zhengzhou, I traded stocks alone for eight months. After my father learned that I was not working and was trading stocks by myself, he called me every day to show concern. In the end he forced me to flatly refuse his calls and block him.
I even felt that I had once reached the edge of depression. Last year Yiyi told me she envied me for having good parents who could send me abroad. I said: Not at all. It is just that I know how to tame other people. Is it not very stupid to let people dumber than you dominate you?
Last year, because my younger sister was under great mental pressure from studying, my father lectured her, saying, look, your brother is under a lot of pressure too. I understand his wish to be considerate of his son, but in my heart there was only one cold voice: if it were not for you, I would have no pressure at all. I could happily be a Sanhe dashen (a day laborer living for the moment) and do whatever I wanted.
Once this problem is extended, it involves the discussion of the boundary between the individual and the collective, so-called freedom.
For personal matters, I personally have absolute freedom.
What moral principles I follow, are you fucking qualified to butt in?
I am unfilial; I am not patriotic (or rather, I do not want to be patriotic in the shallow way of an idiot); I do not like Chinese culture (I think all those values and ethics dug out of piles of old paper should all die); I do not like Chinese food; I am a lifelong hater of Chinese medicine; I do not like the Chinese-style relationship society (I do not feel much tender warmth, only all kinds of exhaustion, comparison, and involution); when I change places I want to forget my roots completely (because the roots I was born into have nothing fucking progressive about them); I do not even want to teach my children Chinese in the future.
All those people who use their own morality and value system to frame us are directly violating us.
To extend it a little further, points two, three, and four above involve the discussion of public rights.
In public areas, of course you have the right to talk about your own views.
But if you are certain that you are right, or if a voice that clearly deviates from the facts is too loud, or if you assert your rights too strongly in public areas, in fact that also constitutes an offense, an invasion of my part of public rights.
It is like in a public living room: you forcefully demand that everyone obey the rules you set, even if the rules you set are optimal for the whole.
Occasionally making some idiotic remarks is excusable, and friends will tolerate it, but if they are spammed again and again, sometimes it makes people feel noisy.
For example: when articles by people like Lu Kewen, Zhanhao, and Wuya Xiaowei go viral, those who believe them treat them as truth and hype them to the skies. Depending on my mood, I may push back a little, so that the world does not fall into the hands of idiots.
As for the fifth point, I have no right to butt in; it is purely out of concern for a friend.
III. On Silent Judgment
so far so good.
The only thing worth examining is “silent judgment”.
Does a mere look from someone, words not yet spoken, constitute a reason for us to fight back?
It does. Although it does not in law, in interpersonal relations it does.
A look, silent judgment, words not spoken, feelings conjured from nothing, causes and conditions that are “without self-nature, without substance, and unobtainable”… all these subtle emotions between people… Some people will regard them as illusory, but in my view they are all real existences.
Those voices that once echoed loudly in our minds, those emotions that stirred the lake of the human heart for no reason… even if they are gone in an instant, on that axis of past time they did really exist.
But if we react strongly on the basis of these alone, on the one hand there is the possibility of killing by mistake, and on the other hand it also feels a bit like “punishing without instruction”.
In order not to make people feel that we are too incomprehensible, and in order for cooperation between people to proceed normally, remember in the future to point things out and explain before fighting back, to give people a chance.
This is what is called “courtesy before force”.
IV. On Arrogance
Why do I remain indifferent and unadorned even when I know I am arrogant?
In fact, what I fear more than arrogance is becoming indistinguishable from the crowd, losing independent will, and reducing myself to a racecourse for other people’s thoughts and intentions.
Three hundred and sixty days in the year, the wind and frost are sharp and severe.
There are too many people who want to interfere with your independent will. Above, the Party-state brainwashes you; below, parents and family repeatedly press and nag; in between, there are exploding information and pluralistic worldviews and values that can justify anything you say.
According to what I observed some time ago, people’s resistance to brainwashing is far weaker than one imagines. Even if you are clever and quick, with an IQ of 150, with five cartloads of books and a master’s or doctoral degree from a 211985 university, it is still hard to escape the dragnet; there is always one that fits you.
When a whole biased information environment is created for you, unless you have your own independent sources of information, it is almost impossible not to be influenced by all kinds of selective reporting.
Then, in the larger environment, kill off the out-of-line information, so that the wolf posing as the seer, with no one counter-claiming, automatically establishes his identity.
Harder to deal with than this is the violation of an individual’s independent will by a mixture of interest and feeling.
The most common are the various forms of ‘for your own good.’
What makes this hard to handle is the mixture of feeling and interest; without exceptional discernment, one is easily led astray.
Remember one thing: if it is truly for my own good, then leave me the right to make the final call, and accept the result calmly.
Anything that secretly smuggles in selfish intent under the name of advice can all get lost.
Another point about ‘for your own good’ that is hard to detect and hard to guard against is its precondition.
The precondition of ‘for your own good’ is the assumption that we have the same values; in fact, most of the time this does not hold.
Some people may use confidence to distinguish arrogance. But I cannot tell the difference.
Could the difference come from results?
If the result is right, it is confidence; if the result is wrong, it is arrogance.
But something derived from after-the-fact results is not enough to constitute an ex ante criterion.
What made me choose the strategy of arrogance was those active forms of evil.
They are either the cleverness of self-serving self-interest or the stupidity of blind conceit.
These are all too common in my world.
So when Qiang Ge told me to change, I had reservations and leaned toward not changing.
Looking back on the more than thirty years of my life, no one has given me much help, nor has anyone done me much harm.
The greatest help to me has all come from encouragement of our confidence and courage;
the greatest harm to me has all come from giving other people’s opinions inappropriate weight.
So those who interfere with others’ independent will in the name of ‘for your own good’ can stop now.
The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Next: Memories of College Life: On Pain and HealingIf this stayed with you, write to me
The FeiThink Library
First published 2020.02.13