The FeiThink Library · Standalone
About the Milk Business
3 min
Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.
A couple of days ago in the philosophy salon group chat I watched members argue fiercely about the milk business. I did not want to wade into muddy water at the time, but I do think a few remarks are in order. Debate makes the truth clearer.
On Choosing Milk
My suggestion is Guangming (Bright Dairy): you support a national brand without making things hard on yourself.
Note: I meant to paste a list of safe brands I had seen on Weibo a few days ago, but when I went back to look, it was gone.
So keep your eyes peeled, each according to his own wits.
Yili and Mengniu can be struck off the shopping list on the strength of the halal label alone. This has nothing to do with religious belief: it is the low quality-control standard that those two characters stand for.
If a national brand can be destroyed by a little reasonable suspicion, or even by a single rumor, then destroying it is no great loss. It never had the capacity to compete in a market at all.
Compared with these individuals, you are a corporate giant, with more information resources and better legal support. If you still cannot win consumers over with a straightforward, well-grounded case, what business do you have in any fiercer market competition?
Destroying these national brands would let the ones better able to withstand the test of the market survive and do better, Guangming for instance. Why not?
Since When Is a “Patriot” a Synonym for “Tough Guy”?
In an era of war against invasion, there was at least some basis for it.
But using the machinery of the state to suppress dissenting speech: supporting that, by any reading, takes no courage at all.
To be unbent by power and force: this is what is meant by a great man.
On What the Capital Market Actually Tests
At least in China’s domestic capital market the testing function is very weak. The reason Luckin was exposed and severely punished is that the U.S. SEC regulates it.
In the Chinese market, a company like Zhangzidao, whose fraud was nailed down by the CSRC with high-tech means, can still hit limit-up board after limit-up board.
The examples are countless. Kangmei Pharmaceutical, after serious fraud, was fined a mere 600,000 yuan, which is practically an encouragement to fraud.
No Investigation, No Right to Speak?
On this I have nothing but a sigh.
Modern society rests on a division of labor, and for ordinary people the news media are our eyes and ears.
If the news media are without conscience, that calls for legislation and regulation. But their function remains irreplaceable.
Now that investigative journalism has come infinitely close to extinction, how much capacity do ordinary people have for deep investigation?
I used to believe firmly that “no investigation, no right to speak”, but these days I cannot bring myself to say it.
When ordinary people have doubts, those who hold the information advantage, whether individuals or corporate persons, ought to make a case that ordinary people can follow and be convinced by, rather than trotting out “Have you ever been to China?” or “Do you know anything about Yili?”, let alone bringing out raw power to crush people (including the cross-province invitation to tea, the deletion of posts, the silencing).
The above is one person’s modest view. Where it is open to dispute, please comment.
The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Next: On the Spirit of Yugong Moving the MountainsIf this stayed with you, write to me
The FeiThink Library
First published 2020.07.23