The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Notes on Thirty Lectures on Comparative Politics
6 min
Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.
Finished Liu Yu’s Thirty Lectures on Comparative Politics in one day.
A few interesting points, listed plainly for your enjoyment:
1. Political science has no common sense
You think democracy is common sense, but many great thinkers were anti-democratic;
you think freedom is common sense, but the left will ask: whose freedom? Is there freedom without class character?
you think equality is common sense, but the historical pursuit of equality has more often than not ended in crushing tragedy.
Sometimes I despair at this standing in place of political knowledge.
Human beings can already ascend the heavens and burrow into the earth, summon wind and call down rain, and still they will beat one another bloody over whether a person may leave a religion, pay a heavy price for one jarring remark, be reduced to a guinea pig of an experiment one cannot exit for the sake of a slogan, turn into enemies over a single election.
A lack of common sense is not necessarily a bad thing.
If knowledge were exact, despotism would be necessary.
If the knowledge of the natural sciences is building a tower that accumulates layer upon layer, the knowledge of the social sciences is more like Sisyphus pushing his stone.
Some may think Sisyphus’s effort futile, not knowing that standing in place may be precisely the resistance to free fall.
This matches my own impression: whether in observing reality or in the history of thought, my deep sense is that political science has stood in place for millennia.
The political civilizations that do well today have not stepped outside Aristotle’s judgment: the state governed by law, democratic in quantity, aristocratic in quality.
Politics creates possibility, but politics has its limits.
The upper limit politics can reach is not very high, but the lower limit it can reach can be very low.
When politics is very bad, when a totalitarian government holds everything, it can destroy people’s incentive to produce, spontaneous social organization, the family, even human nature, and turn life into a nightmare.
When politics is very good, it merely sets relatively fair rules. Good politics is fated to be only the first half of a good life; the second half depends on the creativity and the capacity for cooperation of society, the market and individuals.
This asymmetry is political realism.
Fair rules of the game do not necessarily make a thrilling match, but they are the premise of any sustainable game.
2. Where there is oppression, is there resistance?
Wrong.
The theory of political opportunity holds: where there is opportunity for resistance, there and only there does resistance arise.
This is a truth self-evident, yet only today has someone finally laid it out for me as a theory.
So the application of the conclusion is equally self-evident: democratic transition will not happen in China in the short term.
3. Democratic transition
The process of democratic transition is accompanied by disorder and conflict in almost every country.
Historically, democratic transition has never been plain sailing; it is storm and stress, rise and fall, two steps forward and one step back, sometimes two steps forward and three steps back.
There is no shortcut in the transformation of a political civilization; it must pass through the hearts of thousands upon thousands of people.
If you ask where the idea of civil rights first arose,
the answer is much the same everywhere: the Enlightenment of three hundred years ago.
In a sense one can say that since the modern era only one revolution has taken place in world political history, the revolution in the idea that sovereignty resides in the people; every other revolution is merely its tributary.
Why were a few white men of several hundred years ago so able to bewitch the mind? Was the whole world brainwashed by a handful of Western thinkers?
The fatal attraction of Enlightenment thought lies not in its coming from the West, but precisely in its coming from within us.
Enlightenment is not stuffing some foreign thought into our heads; it is taking a lamp and lighting up what was already there at the bottom of our hearts.
4. The free market
There is no such thing as the extension of a spontaneous order; so-called market freedom is itself a political process.
The existence and development of the market both require the protection of property rights.
When I discussed with friends their case for the free market, we differed somewhat.
Is the principle of equal opportunity at odds with the idea of the free market?
Is a full jungle society the truly free market?
My view agrees with Liu Yu’s.
Capitalism was built up together with the establishment of private property rights.
And that protection of property rights was itself established and refined alongside constraints on absolute monarchy and cutbacks in aristocratic privilege; you could call it an early equal rights movement.
The jungle is the state of nature; the free market is assuredly a political construction.
Without property rights and contract, the market cannot persist. The market presupposes the rule of law, and the spirit of law is equal opportunity before the law.
5. Ideology
Ideology is essentially a piece of translation software, rendering a chaotic, disordered world into a meaningful one.
There is nothing novel in that sentence. But I especially want to mark it.
The deeper I dig, the more I find meaning to be void.
My benighted head has slowly begun to understand a few postmodern things, nihilism for one, whose representative is my favorite Rick&Morty. The so-called “good and evil are man-made.”
Even if it is wrong, if most people believe it, the idea itself constitutes an important social fact, and social facts have social consequences.
This sentence overlaps with my earlier argument, in the piece refuting Zhongguo Lidai Zhengzhi Deshi.
6. Poverty vs. the gap between rich and poor
Mankiw says that what truly matters is, in essence, the problem of poverty, not the problem of inequality as such.
This view runs against my earlier view. Flag it.
Poverty and inequality: which one really matters more?
Disproportionate pessimism may satisfy the intellectual’s passion to remake the world, but it may lead to the wrong way of framing the problem.
7. A cultural map
Finally, an interesting map, which may serve as a reference for those emigrating.
My own preference is the upper right corner: Protestant Europe.
Finally, some nonsense, my own impressions.
1. Liu Yu’s material is by and large proper and conventional.
Introductory popularization of political science.
How to put it. It reads short on brilliance.
A woman scholar whose gifts have not yet risen above the horizon.
Too much emotional appeal, too much of the inspirational-chicken-soup kind of content.
Short on insights that genuinely make the eyes light up.
2. Is this thing called politics worth a great deal of time and study?
Because, as said above, the basic framework of good politics has barely changed in millennia.
Generation after generation merely push the same stone.
Political change, too, is usually counted in generations.
From the standpoint of history, an individual life is far too small and too brief.
If you study these things hoping to come up with something without precedent, that is indeed the intellectual’s conceit.
If you do it purely out of interest, then there is truly an inexhaustible possibility in it, a whole view of the magnificent sweep of human civilization.
3. For an individual, what is a way of life?
To quote a political and economic blogger I like, Lao Wang:
strive with all your might for freedom (of wealth and of thought),
strive with all your might for elegance (showing off),
strive with all your might for a sanctimonious air (the pursuit of righteousness and of sympathy).
The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Next: History of Thought [03]: How to Be HappyIf this stayed with you, write to me
The FeiThink Library
First published 2021.02.26