The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Heroes and the Times

3 min

Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.

(I did not realize this before.) I now feel more and more that a powerful leader’s influence on a community truly exceeds what I had imagined, from as small as a group chat or a school to as large as a society or a country.

Historical materialism teaches us that heroes merely ride the tide of the times and the will of the people; if Napoleon had not burst onto the scene, someone else would have replaced him.

But looking at our actual situation, what deep-seated popular will has the rise of nationalism conformed to? It is not as if a hundred years ago there really was the danger of national destruction and extinction, or the fact of being oppressed by the great powers. For the past twenty years we have been on the winning side of globalization. Why do we feel such bitter grievance? Apart from “heroes” making the times, I really cannot think of any other reason.


In a reading group chat we discussed: for a school, is it more important to have good teachers or good students? I used to think good students were more important.

I have recently been comparing graduates of Tsinghua and Peking University, and I think the influence of something like culture is real, not illusory. As for the pool of excellent students, domestically no other schools can match these two, and between the two schools they are neck and neck, hard to separate. But one clearly feels that what Tsinghua turns out is really mostly red and expert engineers, and their humanities and social science literacy is abysmal. In my WeChat Moments there were quite a few Tsinghua students who in the past couple of days supported forwarding Xianggang zhe zuo chengshi hai you jiu ma; those outstanding graduates likewise cannot tell right from wrong. When an honorary degree was awarded to Putin, a bunch of people in the alumni group chats loudly cheered. Compared with the way various alumni groups at Peking University were all shut down last month, the contrast is truly stark. And this red and expert culture at Tsinghua began precisely with President Jiang Nanxiang.


Someone said: Tsinghua’s positioning is mainly science and engineering, and its positioning in cultivating talent is different from Peking University’s.

But this cannot justify ignorance or numbness. If one lacks specialized, profound humanities and social science literacy and cannot make firm choices, should one not at least retain the ability to tell right from wrong? If right and wrong are also hard to distinguish, then at least one should harbor the doubt that ‘I might be wrong.’

Writing to this point, I jump to Pavlov’s dog. The mechanism by which culture works seems to be precisely this: through various positive and negative feedbacks, real or imagined, it is projected onto people’s consciousness and modes of behavior, forming conditioned reflexes. Take ‘Actions speak louder than words,’ the second school motto, as an example: I do not know how many times it has been used to suppress radical speech. There are many such examples. If you look, you will see.

Heaven and Earth are not humane; they treat the myriad things as straw dogs. The sage is not humane; he treats the people as straw dogs.

To speak without emotional coloring: human beings are not much more exalted than straw dogs, whether you are an American dog, a Chinese dog, a Japanese dog, or an Arab dog.

With enough manpower, material resources, power, and intelligence, the possibility of transforming social ideology absolutely exists.

Reality seems to remind us that the possibility is still very great.

P.S. Having written the above, I actually still want to explore in detail the mechanism by which culture shapes consciousness, but this topic is too large, so I note it down for now.

P.S.S. And what kind of person, or under what conditions a person can escape this external influence and preserve his own free will and capacity for independent thought.

The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Next: Rereading Shen Pangpang

If this stayed with you, write to me

New volumes arrive here

Email RSS

Heroes and the Times
The FeiThink Library
First published 2019.07.12

Fei Huang · Writes from Amsterdam on Kant, Dostoevsky, and the moral life.