The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Notes on Nan Qingnian Ze'ou Zhinan (A Guide to Mate Selection for Young Men)
13 min
Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.
To me, marriage means something.
To me, marriage still carries considerable weight.
Something this important deserves some time and clear thought.
So I will write myself a guidebook, and then start acting on it.
I racked my brains for two days and came up with only two criteria, ‘value’ and ‘IQ’.
Then I found a curious piece online: Nan Qingnian Ze’ou Zhinan.
The author lists fifty items in one go.
His experience is far richer than mine;
his insight is so deep that it matches what I have learned from years of judging people;
his wording is so sharp that it says what I dare not say.
There is a scene before my eyes I cannot put into words; Cui Hao’s poem is already there above.
Faced with such a magisterial text, why should I bother writing my own? All I can do is quote it directly to spread its glory.
From the original 50 items I select 19, shuffle and rearrange them according to my own understanding, and add further commentary where the original leaves something unsaid (in blue).
I. Worldview
1. Very few women are truly suited to marriage
In any field, true talent is extremely rare. Marriage is no exception: women who would truly make good wives and mothers are extremely rare.
Most women are simply not suited to marriage, and most marriages are just muddled through.
Keep looking for an excellent partner suited to marriage. If you find one, you must hold on to her; if you do not, keep looking.
Someone may ask: are you yourself a person of talent, to be demanding this and that?
In fact, I think anyone who regards marriage as an extremely important matter and can finish the original without jumping up in disgust already counts as a person of talent; their cognitive ability is already stronger than that of most ignorant, uncomprehending people.
Also, a recent lesson from trading stocks: if you cannot find a great stock, then better to stay in cash than to move randomly and get trapped.
Munger’s so-called rule of no mediocre investments.
2. Only people who have not found an ideal partner are indiscriminate
Only those who have never seen a good woman and never experienced a harmonious relationship think they can date anyone and sleep with anyone.
All good things share one trait: they are not downward compatible.
3. A woman’s youth is not so precious as to be priceless, and is mostly worth little
Those girls who use their youth to study hard, work, grow, master a skill, and attain relatively high intelligence and quality have an unlimited future; their youth is truly priceless.
But those girls who use their youth to fool around, be EasyGirls, indulge in sensual pleasures, or even take drugs: their youth is not only worth little, it is a huge debt.
II. Methodology
4. Do not hang yourself from one tree
Usually, meet more girls; only with a large base is there room to choose.
If you like her, pursue her; if you find she is unsuitable, immediately pursue another. Do not hesitate, do not get immersed.
A man’s mate-selection strategy is different from a woman’s; as a man you should hold to one principle:
If it does not work, change.
5. Do not casually establish a relationship
Do not be too impatient. Rashly establishing a relationship brings endless trouble.
It takes time to see through a person; the probationary period may as well be longer.
6. Practice as much as possible, but do not toy with girls
Having the ability to be a scumbag and actually being a scumbag are two different things. It is only to keep you from being a brainless man fooled by women, from being a simp who gives without any bottom line, from being the naive STEM guy who, when he meets a bitch, has no ability to fight back and can only jump off a building.
The value of an excellent partner is worth your self-discipline.
III. Ideal Type
7. For marriage, choose a strong contender in the marriage market
A girl who is young, beautiful, capable, has family property, and is pursued by many. Among several high-quality suitors she actively chose you; this is also the best proof that she loves you.
8. Prefer girls who are good at studying, but do not fetishize degrees
Being good at studying means being obedient, diligent, steady, and intelligent; these are all qualities of a good wife and good mother.
If a man is too obedient, it shows a lack of stubborn spirit, and he will find it hard to achieve much; for a woman, being conservative and obedient is a good quality.
Try not to choose girls with poor academic records: they are either stupid or lazy, and most likely both lazy and stupid.
9. Prefer girls with good fortune
Good fortune is an important bonus; for the sake of good fortune one can concede on money and looks.
If you marry a woman who is tart and mean, withdrawn and cold, you will gradually find that relatives and friends interact with you less, your family atmosphere becomes oppressive, your temper worsens, your career becomes more bumpy, and so on. If you marry a woman who is gentle and virtuous, has a soft presence, and is optimistic and open-minded, you will find that she prospers you in every respect.
To see whether a person has good fortune, mainly see whether she has the character genes to become the old grandmother who connects the family’s affections, whether children like her, whether she maintains good relationships with relatives and friends, and so on.
10. Prefer girls willing to have more children
Girls unwilling to have children, or willing to have only 1 child, are often relatively more selfish and more ambitious.
Girls willing to have 2 or more children are more willing to live a family life and are more suitable as wives.
It seems that not having children has now become a fashionable idea.
I cannot agree. A thing is not automatically correct because it is avant-garde and trendy.
Some people do not want children because of childhood wounds,
some because of the pressure of circumstances,
some because raising children is hard…
I can understand all of this, but after understanding all of it I still choose to have and raise more.
Children are not as fragile as we think, and parents do not need to be all-capable to raise them.
The key is companionship: parents are there when the child needs them.
And family is wealth, worth giving up some of our selfishness and ambition for.
IV. Exclusions
11. Not bringing a bitch home to marry is the greatest filial piety to your parents
Marriage is by no means a joke. Marrying the wrong wife is equal to ruining the future of three generations.
If you plan to marry a girl, you must know her roots and bottom. To know her roots is to understand the circumstances of the two generations above her; to know her bottom is to be completely clear about all her past experiences.
A person is shaped by experience; only experience can fully reflect a person.
12. Make much of older age, but date young girls
Why can’t older women marry? Essentially because no man wants to become family with them.
For me, the obstacle of older age is that I want to raise several children, and older age makes that more troublesome.
And frankly, dating young girls is much more interesting.
That youthful vitality, that feeling of youth, are gifts of nature, making one feel that chemistry is not entirely a bad thing.
13. Support tianyuan nüquan (pastoral feminism) but choose good girls
When you encounter tianyuan nüquan, support them on the surface while secretly observing who joins the clamor. This helps, at lower cost, to filter out the domineering women, brainless women, perverted women, and so on around you who are unsuitable for marriage.
14. Do not marry an incompetent peacock girl from an urban underclass native family
The urban underclass native is the dregs precipitated by the city’s operation. If a peacock girl is unremarkable in study, work, and overall quality, she is by no means a good marriage object. Such families often have the strongest petty urbanite mentality and are more snobbish than ordinary rural families.
By contrast, phoenix girls of rural origin have higher overall quality and are not a bad choice.
Here people are classified by origin and ability.
A very realistic and very helpless general observation is this: the closer to the bottom, the more people’s thinking tends toward involution and mutual harm.
I have another conjecture: the higher one’s ability, the more effectively one can cut off from one’s family of origin and class.
This is a principle of human selection: if one cannot cut effectively, even a genius will become mediocre and will not display striking ability.
The general range of choice is the area above the slanted line in the figure below.
Further extension: (setting aside whether one can marry her at all) can an incompetent middle-class woman or rich family’s daughter be married?
So perhaps the straight line is not the best fit; a better fit is an upward-curving arc.
15. Stay away from free-range village chickens in the city
Many girls of rural and small-city origin have ordinary ability and above-average looks, attended a university that is neither good nor bad, and are single-mindedly bent on hooking a wealthy husband and staying in the big city. If their family of origin lacked love, they will be relatively cold inside, have the strongest sense of comparison and utilitarianism, and often adopt relatively aggressive mate-selection strategies. As long as a man’s conditions are good, they will actively come forward and try to lock him down by sleeping with him; as soon as he is unsuitable, they will break up at once. They only want to gain benefits and will not truly love you.
Here, beyond origin and ability, considerations of resources and motives are added, along with the strategic choices formed thereby.
Ordinary people really find it hard to transcend their environment. In similar situations, the choices people make are often highly uniform.
We, with all our scheming and being too clever by half, our extreme utilitarianism and Machiavellianism, are merely trying to impose an anti-gravity field on ourselves, so that in later married life we will not need to be too complicated, using extreme complexity in the process to achieve a simple and beautiful result.
We were to meet in freedom.
Dogville
16. Choose cautiously girls with a short gap between relationships
The length of the gap between relationships can show whether she is cold inside and whether she is fickle.
A girl whose gap is relatively short (less than 3 months), or who even moves seamlessly from one relationship to the next, is not suitable to marry.
A short gap means a high probability of being entangled with her ex, and she is certainly more likely than other girls to cheat. A short gap also shows that this girl has invested insufficient energy in hobbies and career, and is very likely a selfish, incompetent girl.
Extending this point, the option of poaching and choosing a girl who already has a boyfriend is also excluded.
V. Items for Examination
17. Focus on what she can do well
Girls who show off travel, baking, fitness, diving, keeping dogs, and so on every day are mostly brain-dead women addicted to sensual pleasures. Do not mistake them for glamorous, pretty, and interesting.
Pay more attention to a girl’s ability to do housework, her ability to learn, her ability to work, her ability to get along with people, whether she has a skill, and so on. Only a girl with these solid, practical abilities is suitable to be a wife.
18. Look at how much she is willing to give for you
A selfish woman knows only how to take; her love is not worth a penny.
A selfish person is certainly an incompetent person. They do nothing but take, take, take and complain, complain, complain. Making a life with them will surely ruin your life.
19. See whether she makes you compete with others
Women like to be competed over by many men; this greatly satisfies their vanity. But women have another trait: if she truly loves a man, that man will shine in her eyes, and every other man compared with him is a dog. She would never be willing to make him compete with others.
If you find that a girl intentionally makes you compete with other men for her, then you must give up decisively.
VI. Supplementary Items
20. On political stance
Two days ago a friend asked me: will I include political stance in my considerations?
This is indeed a recent confusion of mine.
In the end, is it a question of values or a question of intelligence?
I tend not to consider it too much.
Politics is a profession, a skill that, like driving or trading stocks, requires long-term training to acquire.
If my political stance were the benchmark, then more than 90% of Chinese women would be excluded.
That is quite unnecessary.
The political views I have formed to date are the combined result of my close reading of history since childhood + my long-standing interest in and attention to social politics + a basic understanding of modern civilization theory + rich social experience.
I have seen the social ecology of rural feudal clans and the organizational forms of urban civil society; I have seen both the extreme waste of social resources by enterprises under the state-owned system and the exploitation of labor by private enterprises.
As the original author said: experience shapes a person.
If my level of understanding only leaves me stuck on these surface things, then I do not deserve to say I have high intelligence.
Specific political views are not of much reference value; they are merely the product of a person’s particular standpoint, perspective, and information horizon.
What deserves attention is not the black and white of a political stance, but the complexity of thought displayed in the process of analysis.
Being able to get past the firewall and know a few things others do not know is nothing to be smug about.
Conversely, when much information is missing, being able to reach basically correct conclusions by relying on one’s plain logic and the light of human nature is a major plus.
To put it plainly: having it is very good; not having it is no cause for blame.
What I cannot tolerate is reverse discrimination.
Arrogance is an obstacle to survival. Being arrogant in front of someone more capable than you is a move that makes me feel that no matter how high your intelligence seemed before, it can be reset to zero afterward.
Writing this, I suddenly feel that this is the influence of ‘modesty’, one of the dregs of traditional culture, on me.
In fact, habitual arrogance beforehand does not constitute an exclusion criterion either. Because smart people are mostly proud, and people who do not consider themselves smart are mostly genuinely not smart. Those who cannot bear to see arrogance in others are in fact more arrogant than anyone (myself included).
Only arrogance that departs from reality after full exchange and confrontation is a manifestation of bad judgement or low intelligence.
In the end, what I cannot tolerate is bad judgement.
This is all I have thought of for now. I will add more whenever things come to mind later.
I will conclude with a conversation with a German girl, Anna:
I said I wanted to make a plan for marriage: first, clarify the criteria; second, do marketing.
Anna said:
Life NEVER goes according to plans.
Life never plays its cards according to plan.
I: my life goes.
The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Next: On IQ Snobbery and ArroganceIf this stayed with you, write to me
The FeiThink Library
First published 2020.02.19