The FeiThink Library · Standalone

How to Quarrel Correctly

6 min

Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.

Recently I have been struck by the quarrels between wumao (the fifty-cent commenters) and meifen (the American-cent commenters) that are visible everywhere; even Moucao, a gentlemanly community, cannot escape them.
So let us talk about how to quarrel correctly with people.

I. How to Hold the Truth in Your Hand

When I examine my own system of knowledge, I find a great deal that can be grasped only in the mind and not put into words.
My analysis of phenomena relies on my innate speculative capacity and my acquired logical training. That is more than enough to let me surpass ordinary people by a little, but not enough to make me a great master who has integrated everything into one whole.

Some people are satisfied with half-understood conclusions; that is not the level at which we want to stop. We must not only know and distinguish right from wrong, true from false; we must also examine more deeply the real spirit and principle behind them.
To put it in a more pretentious, show-offy way: I want to understand the truth behind this world.

If the search for truth is the objective function, for now I can think only of brute-force algorithms.

First, we need to study philosophy systematically.
My current tools of thought are science and reason: so-called verified knowledge, quantitative methods, putting oneself in another’s place, and the capacity for abstraction from phenomena to essence.
I sat in on a few philosophy classes at Fudan, with the intuition that there might be something useful in them. The teacher said that reason and empiricism are Kant’s position, while Hegel’s dialectic is a higher-order existence. I’ll see.

Of course it is not limited to philosophy; there is also law, history, sociology, geopolitics, natural philosophy… Most of what we think about has already been thought about by our predecessors. People who reinvent it independently are impressive, of course, but why not stand on the shoulders of giants and push on to the frontier?

Second, we cannot neglect broad experience and observation, or deep involvement in the social division of labor and cooperation.
By analogy with model training in machine learning, experience and observation are the data used to train the model; deep participation in the social division of labor and cooperation helps explain the model’s principles; scientific thinking, engineering methods, and philosophy are the algorithms that train the model.
Some people ask why Han Han could not write incisive articles after thirty. One reason is that he has not really participated deeply in the broad social division of labor and cooperation. Thus he can mock and rant and attack current abuses, but if he wants to write something genuinely deep and constructive, that is still far from enough.

II. How to Label People Correctly

We don’t quarrel with idiots.
We do not quarrel with idiots.
I am neither a public intellectual nor a saint. I have no interest in enlightening the ignorant.
I just find life flavorless and look for a little amusement for myself.
I once went after a big influencer on Weibo and set off a 1-against-200 flame war. I had hoped to hear something worthwhile from so many people, but the result disappointed me greatly.

I once spent thought and time studying how to classify people, but honestly there is still no systematic method.
Intellectual talent? That seems insufficient. I have seen it on my WeChat Moments: a Tsinghua undergraduate, a Peking University PhD… and it is still not enough to support them in reaching reasonable and coherent conclusions.
Intellectual talent plus some competence in the relevant discipline? That might be a very good classifier, but I always feel something is still missing. For I have also seen people who have both, yet are trapped in their own position and narrative, without some higher perspective and capacity for abstraction.

For now it seems we can still rely only on manual work, classifying by our own experience and sense of smell.
For example, a girl in a reading group who works in HR said that MBTI theory is used only in the field of human resources. With one sentence she exposed herself as a half-baked dabbler who cannot grasp the essence at all, someone who attends to the is rather than the ought.

III. How to Avoid Being Labeled

Even my smartest classmates, once they slap the label ‘your-country party’ on me, stop listening to anything I say, even when I think what I am telling them is a fact.
We must avoid being labeled as much as possible. Otherwise the person quarreling with us covers his ears early on, and if we cannot freely and with evidence prove that he is an idiot, what is the point?

So, we must observe the following principles:

1. Stay calm as much as possible.

No matter how much you despise nonsense like ‘the modest gentleman is warm as jade’, no matter how much you believe in a maxim like ‘the man who is not extreme has no foresight’.
Getting angry and flustered damages your cool.

2. No slogans and no empty talk.

In recent years public intellectuals have been systematically stigmatized by government propaganda.
Although what they say is good, first they cannot prove it in plain and accessible terms, and second they cannot offer systematic solutions.
To say only things that are either high-sounding or correct but useless is indeed very feeble.

We will say nothing of grand slogans and will not presuppose our own position.
We will derive our conclusions step by step only from the facts and data we know and see.

IV. How to Despise and Insult Others Correctly

We do not call people idiots; we prove that they are.

V. How to Face Contempt and Insult Correctly

In a philosophy class I asked the teacher how to get started and the whole class laughed at me, which made me very unhappy.
I thought to myself: hmph, you mediocre talents, how dare you laugh at your superior deity.
But I cannot prove it. Life is full of such moments when one cannot argue back.

Why then was I so confident? After all, they were all Fudan students.
In college I was clearly a loser, yet I deferred to no one. Only many years later did I understand why.
Of course stubborn self-esteem was at work, but that is not the main point, because if that were all, I would have been unconvinced in speech but admiring in my heart, not unconvinced from the bottom of my heart.
The more important reason is that I believed what they had over me was stock knowledge, while what I prided myself on was my ability to discover the truth.
I wish I know it earlier, or someone told me earlier that I am the best.

Back to the point: how should we face contempt and insult correctly?
Borrowing a line from a hot-blooded shonen manga:

Just set your goal as high as possible; if others laugh, let them laugh.

After all,

hito no yume o wa ra ne
People’s dreams will never end.

PS:
As for how to get started in philosophy, I think what I asked was indeed a stupid question.
How to get started? (The following answer applies equally to many other things for which one cannot find the door.)
We kick the door in directly.
We kick the door.

The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Next: A Simple Patriotic Function

If this stayed with you, write to me

New volumes arrive here

Email RSS

How to Quarrel Correctly
The FeiThink Library
First published 2019.10.13

Fei Huang · Writes from Amsterdam on Kant, Dostoevsky, and the moral life.