The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Misogyny

6 min

Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.

Lately I have wanted to get a systematic understanding of feminism.

On Douban I often come across women cursing out guonan (Chinese men, spelled with the character for “larva”), and it is harsher on Twitter, where diao and lü get denounced together.

I cannot turn a blind eye to the demands of half of humanity and still advertise my own integrity.

The other thing is how my view of feminism changed. My attitude used to be neutral leaning negative, because what I mostly saw were people seeking privilege and dodging responsibility. Until the white paper.


Knowing I must belong among the misogynists, I wanted to check myself first, to see how far gone I was. So I read Misogyny.

My overall reaction after finishing: is this what a nine-out-of-ten book looks like?

The logic and method are dubious, the depth limited. It is little more than the repeated application of a fixed set of value judgments, with no real care to explain why things are so.

At first I wondered whether I was this irritable because I had set my heart on finding answers and failed, or because of my male perspective. Then the top-voted one-star review on Douban dispelled both doubts:

“The cases are never analyzed clearly, the theory is used confusedly and wrongly, the wording is recklessly imprecise: a hodgepodge.”

Two examples:

  1. Pavlov’s dog.

    The book opens with exactly this kind of language. It sounds satisfying; there is a pleasure in cursing.

    But is this something you can put forward as an argument? Because men and women alike are all Pavlov’s dogs; no one escapes biology entirely. There is not even a difference of degree between the two, only of concealment: men are just more obvious about it.

    The problem with the hundred-kill men is not their biological instinct but that they treat people as tools.

  2. XX is only a man’s fantasy, not a real woman.

    This pushes the question to the point of agnosticism: what is real?

    Is a woman’s understanding of herself real? Can a woman’s understanding of men not equally be treated as fantasy?

    This feels like an irresponsible sophistical trick. It can certainly refute others, but then do not expect to have any views of your own.

    …
    I will not list the rest one by one; mainly I felt they were not worth digging into.

Of course all of the above is me nitpicking.

A touch of feeling when pointing out a problem, a little exaggeration in wording, counts for nothing.

Better to read in a learning frame of mind, to try harder to understand what the other person is really trying to say.

Next, what I got out of it:

  1. 1. Men’s homosocial

“Men prefer the company of men.

A man’s value is decided by the hegemonic struggle in the world of men.

A woman’s value is fixed by men’s choices (supposedly).”

These observations are still apt.

And even if I can see it, I still feel I cannot get free of it.

For instance, I no longer care about the approval of the homosocial world of men, and I am just as repelled by (male) people thick with paternal condescension. But even if I take a dim view of the worldly and turn to pursue something else, I still hope to meet an evenly matched adversary, and I long for the understanding and appreciation of my own kind. And for reasons I do not understand, there are few women on this road. As Kant says, deep meditation and a long-sustained reflection are difficult, and do not well befit the unconstrained and beautiful.

This probably counts as a kind of homosocial too.

  1. 2. Women’s integrity toward the body

Woman belongs to the body; man governs the body.

A woman curses herself her whole life as the body’s slave, while a man pays his whole life the price of making the body other.

Man’s disgust at the body, his wish to be rid of it, can be called man’s chronic illness.

If a man is to accept a whole self, he has to be reconciled with himself, body included.


The book is finished, but my doubts are clearly not resolved.

And it is not only discrimination against women. Discrimination of every kind, in the broadest sense, is still something I have not thought through.

As when I was talking with Mark a couple of days ago: Mark said the less you assume, the closer you get to the truth.

My question is this:

On not making assumptions about people: are we to treat someone by the average standard first, until he actually deviates from the average?

But if some group keeps repeatedly showing traits that deviate from the average?

Then the next time you meet someone from that group:

Should you go on by the overall average, or by the average of that group?

If I keep to the overall average without adjusting, am I a blockhead? Unrepentant.

But if I treat people by the average of that group, is that not just discrimination?

This is the question I still have not worked out.

Right now it is roughly two positions wrestling in me: on the left the principled integrity, on the right Nietzsche’s voice, that sympathy, humility and pity are the virtues of the weak, and the virtues of the strong are self-confidence and magnanimity.

The interesting thing is that Kant, the man who proposed a “universal moral principle”, also discriminated against women.

I am curious how he excluded women from the scope of rational beings and kept his integrity.

Kant holds that

the qualities of both sexes are a combination of the beautiful and the sublime: women lean toward the beautiful, men toward the sublime.

A woman’s understanding lies not in the power of reasoning but in the power of feeling.

Man follows moral principles, woman follows feeling.

A man’s morality consists in obeying universal principles, forcing himself to accept the moral command.

But woman can bear no command and no unpleasant compulsion. She makes moral judgments not by universal laws but by the cases around her.

It looks harmless enough, just a description of two different sets of traits.

But the trouble is that in Kant’s system reason counts for far more than feeling.

True virtue can only rest on principles, and the more universal the principle the more sublime the virtue; the beautiful is merely an auxiliary impulse.

Mm. Noted.

The trick to keeping your integrity is learning to adjust the scope of moral subjects flexibly, excluding the unreasonable. (doge


My doubts are still not dispelled.

Next I will probably read Kant first. His categorical imperative and the test by its three formulas should help me understand moral questions at a deeper level.

And for philosophy, Kant is a mountain you cannot go around. If you want to feel the power of thought, he cannot be avoided.

Reading order: Political Writings -> Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals -> Critique of Pure Reason

Finally, if you have read this far, I welcome your recommendations of feminist reading, or of discussions of discrimination.

References:

  1. Ueno Chizuko, Misogyny, Shanghai Sanlian Bookstore, 2015

  2. Yamaguchi Sayoko, “Writing Pre-feminist Work in a Post-feminist Age”, Douban review, 2021

  3. Nowally Naowuli, “Scorning the woman PhD as bachelor Mr. Kant did”, Sohu article, 2019

The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Next: On Being a Person of Integrity

If this stayed with you, write to me

New volumes arrive here

Email RSS

Misogyny
The FeiThink Library
First published 2023.05.26

Fei Huang · Writes from Amsterdam on Kant, Dostoevsky, and the moral life.