The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Notes on The Wisdom of Stock Trading

7 min

Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.

I. The Characteristics of the Stock Market

The stock-trading business is marked by how hard it is to enter.

From my knowledge and experience of this business, without three years of full-time experience you cannot even get a foot in the door.
You must be prepared to grind.

The illusion of a stock lies not in the value underlying it but in the fantasy it offers the trader.

No one tells you when to enter, and no one tells you when to exit; every decision must be your own, each decision is so difficult, and no decision has fixed rules.
This enduring gamble of the stock market demands that you make rational decisions at every moment and bear full responsibility for the results.

Stock trading is not a science.
Science requires reproducibility; things that are not fully reproducible cannot be studied by scientific methods.
Meet uncertainty with a philosophical and artistic mode of thinking, then respond to it with probabilistic analysis.
The scientific mode of thinking we learned from childhood often becomes an obstacle to success in the stock market.

In this business, conventional right and wrong do not exist, or rather they are meaningless.
The investing public and its view of the future are the only force that moves stock prices.

The stock market has its own laws and its own characteristics. These laws and characteristics are never wholly fixed; they give you only a feeling of having seen it all before.

II. The Process of Learning to Trade

Stock trading is a very old activity, with many precedents of success; it is not an industry that requires genius.
What matters most is perseverance and the courage to overcome yourself.

You are wrestling a giant, and brute force will not do. You must learn technique and never clash with it head-on.
You must understand this giant, become familiar with its habits, and strike at its vital point at the right moment. Only then do you have a chance to win.
Once you find that your attack is ineffective, you must flee and guard against the giant’s retaliation.

Through your own observation and research, keep accumulating experience, raise the probability of winning each time you enter from 50% to 60%, even 70%; and do not stake too much on each entry, only a portion of your principal. Over the long run, you will win by playing long enough.

Learning to trade is the process of learning to look for critical points, and it also includes learning the right mentality for trading.
Frankly, learning the technique of finding critical points is relatively easy; cultivating the mentality is what is truly difficult.
Learning to trade is the process of overcoming innate human nature such as greed and cultivating acquired experience such as non-greed.

By the stage where long play wins, you should have no emotional fluctuation over losing or making money.
You are no longer pained by stop-losses; you understand that they are part of the game. You are no longer elated by profit; you know it is a necessary result.
You no longer take winning and losing to heart; you care only about doing the right thing at the right time. You know profit will follow.

If you can endure 10 years in the stock market, you should be able to keep making money; if you endure 20 years, your experience will have great value for others; if you endure 30 years, then when you retire you will certainly be a very wealthy person.

III. Analysis of Stocks

Value analysis mainly analyzes a company’s small environment; the big environment is too complex, and to judge the big environment one mainly uses the broad stock market.

Technical analysis is reading charts. The four commonly used tools are trend lines, support and resistance lines, head-and-shoulders patterns, and moving averages. In practice one realizes the psychological factors behind them; human nature does not change easily, so they remain effective.
Other patterns, such as triangles, tunnels, and flags, have been shown by practical experience to have little practical value.

Do not look at technical analysis in isolation. Study the broad stock market, study the company’s operations, study the company’s products, then look at the price chart, and pay special attention to changes in trading volume. Only on this foundation does technical analysis have meaning. Most important, remember stop-losses.

Using technical analysis to determine the direction of the broad market and changes in that direction is the most effective tool.
Stock trading is a game of probability; move against the great tide and your probability of winning is sharply reduced.
One tenet of the stock market is to follow the trend, not to predict it. Following the trend and predicting the trend are essentially different in their mode of thinking.

IV. The Practice of Stock Trading

(I) Principles of Speculation

What is the principle of speculation?
Its essence can be condensed into two sentences: 1. Lose without being ruined; 2. Pursue excellence.

Preserve Capital

Keep the concept of preserving capital firmly in mind.

Continuous Profit

To keep making money in the stock market, beyond knowledge and experience you must endure and wait for the moment to make money.
The stock market is sometimes completely disorderly; you simply do not know how a stock will move next.
Only by entering when the odds are certain do you greatly raise your probability of success, and only this makes continuous profit possible.

Make Big Money

As long as a stock is moving normally, you must hold still.
Livermore said that the secret of his trading was not how he thought but that he could sit still after buying right.
Grasping the characteristics of normal stock movement is extremely important for trading.
A professional trader must never be frightened out during a normal pullback.

Once abnormal phenomena appear, you must pay special attention.
When you see a danger signal, do not waver, do not indulge in fantasy; sell the entire position.

(II) The Practice of Speculation

1. When to Buy Stocks

My own method is to use value analysis to find stocks; after finding them, the operations mainly rely on technical analysis.

Use the critical points you yourself have discovered, buy and sell according to rules you have set, train your patience, and watch for danger signals the market provides; then you are on the right path of learning to trade.

Stocks, like people, have their particular personalities: some are conservative and slow, some impatient and restless.
With these stocks that have no affinity with me, I get burned every time I touch them. Try to avoid them.

2. When to Sell Stocks

In a major trend, the head and the tail are very hard to catch; traders should learn to catch the middle section. Catching 70% of the price swing counts as a very good result.
Do not try to find the highest point of a stock.

In my own experience, deciding when to sell a stock is more difficult than deciding when to buy. When you are losing, you hope to break even; when you are winning, you want to win more; the mental struggle goes on without end.
As with buying stocks, the point at which to sell is also a critical point.
If you can enter only at critical buy points and exit only at critical sell points, remember loss on entry, and pay attention to spreading risk, your probability of success will be raised to the highest, and you will truly become a stock-trading expert.

  • Watch for danger signals
    As experience accumulates, you will gradually get the feeling that it is time to sell.
    Do not ignore such intuition; it is experience.
    To acquire such experience, you have usually paid a lot of tuition.
    Believe in yourself.
  • Preserve capital first
  • Lose small amounts
    I myself like to set the stop-loss at the lowest point of the day I enter the market. In my experience, if I have chosen the entry correctly and the stock price starts to rise, it should not fall back to the lowest point of my entry day.
  • When you meet a windfall, take it first
  • Beware when trading volume surges but the stock price does not rise
  • Use a moving stop-loss to sell stocks

Once the market proves you wrong, admit it and exit; if you are right, you can increase your bet.

V. Reflections on Money

A successful life is not merely the acquisition of wealth; it is a state of mind in which you feel serene, tranquil, and satisfied.

It is meaningless to pursue far more money than you need. To achieve that end you will lose too much, and you will be troubled by it.

The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Next: How to Stay Relaxed

If this stayed with you, write to me

New volumes arrive here

Email RSS

Notes on The Wisdom of Stock Trading
The FeiThink Library
First published 2020.04.08

Fei Huang · Writes from Amsterdam on Kant, Dostoevsky, and the moral life.