The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Reflections on Generation War

2 min

Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.

After watching Generation War, I could not help thinking of something else: who exactly writes history? Who exactly decides where the state and society go? Prophets? Emperors?

I think the answer should still be ordinary people of integrity.

They may lack a prophet’s wisdom, may lack an emperor’s power. But as Varys the Spider says in A Song of Ice and Fire, Power resides where men believe it resides. Justice lies in the hearts of the people. It is the people’s faith that constitutes the foundation of power.

In the series, Charlotte and Wilhelm can be called typical representatives of ordinary German men and women of the time. Charl went from being an initial Nazi enthusiast to her later transformation; Wilhelm went from a brave sergeant to a deserter.

Truth is never made clear by talking, nor learned simply by hearing someone out. People must grasp it through something more immediate, something you can see and touch. If for one person only a beating can make things clear, then by the same token the progress of the state and society also requires illusion and failure, bloodshed and tears.

If historical materialism ever taught us anything close to the truth, then ‘history advances in waves and rises in spirals’ counts as one of them. (Of course it is not exact. Some civilizations reach their peak in a single wave and then vanish into the long river of history, so there is no question of advance or rise.)

A few days ago I reposted an article with 100,000+ reads. There was nothing praiseworthy in the article itself. But some data related to the article did catch my attention.

I counted the likes on the first three comments. If we crudely label them ‘left’ and ‘right’,

then, the ratio of left to right is about 6 : 1

(Considering that the author is a military enthusiast, and that military enthusiasts are the group most prone to nationalism, his followers must be predominantly left; but for an article with 100,000+ reads, the audience should far exceed the original follower base, so this effect should be considerably diluted and can be ignored)

In the past I always took it for granted that the people were innocent and that the bad ones were a small clique at the top. But you find that this is not the truth. The truth is closer to this: as the people are, so is the management. It is hard to tell whether the managers have educated the people, or the people have coerced the managers, or whether it is a mutually reinforcing positive feedback loop.

If reality is like this, then they deserve a failure as spectacular as that of the Third Reich, so that they can see things clearly, grow, and recognize and establish the rules and bottom lines they ought to have.

History advances and rises precisely by treading on these rules and bottom lines, rolling forward.

The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Next: Letter to a Friend: Why Emigrate

If this stayed with you, write to me

New volumes arrive here

Email RSS

Reflections on Generation War
The FeiThink Library
First published 2019.06.03

Fei Huang · Writes from Amsterdam on Kant, Dostoevsky, and the moral life.