The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Letter to a Friend: Why Emigrate
7 min
Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.
I. Practical Problems:
1. Hukou (household registration)
In Beijing it is basically impossible; in Shanghai you need a residence permit and 7 years of continuous social-security contributions to convert to hukou.
In Germany, if you find a job, you can convert to permanent residence in as little as 21 months or as long as 33 months, and after 8 years of living there you can naturalize.
2. Housing prices
Being able to buy is actually not bad, but it is not worth it; the main issue is that education and health care are tied to it. Housing prices in big German cities like Munich are also very high, but livability is much higher.
3. Career / Work intensity
In China’s IT industry, 35 is a threshold, and by 40 your career is basically over. If you have not made it by then, it is a real problem. I am confident my life will not come to that, but why insist on being rushed onto the shelf? Labor protection in China is too weak, overtime is severe, and there is no talk of work-life balance. German vacations are longer and work pressure is lower. Although I am in China, I do not even get many days off a year to go home.
4. Children’s education
In China, raising children without grandparents helping is almost impossible: there are all kinds of training classes, picking up and dropping off at school; for both parents to work is almost impossible. But honestly, I do not want my parents to raise the children; our ideas about child-rearing differ too much.
On the whole, East Asia is generally densely populated and fiercely competitive; the educational rat race is too severe. If you stay in China, you must mobilize every resource you can to fight it out.
In this respect, first, I have no competitive advantage accumulated over generations; second, I myself do not want to wade into this muddy water. I know well the defects of education in China: much of what is taught is simply wrong or meaningless, purely for screening people out.
Moreover, the direction of education reform is not improving; it is transforming toward hereditary privilege for the powerful. From the small signs one can see the large, from one falling leaf one knows autumn: you can imagine what society will be like in twenty years.
II. Cultural Problems
1. A society of personal connections
This is also why I cannot go back to a small place; if I can only stay in China, it must be Beijing, Shanghai, or Shenzhen.
2. Money worship
Money above all. Society is restless and people compare themselves with one another. Emotional pressure transmits; once you are inside it, it is almost impossible to escape.
Money worship would be tolerable if accompanied by a sound rule of law and rules. But with disordered money worship plus a lack of professionalism, there are people everywhere in society trying to cheat you out of your money. To live in it, you must spend a great deal of time and energy figuring out all the tricks; the cost is too high. It feels as if only the shrewd can survive.
3. Nationalism
Over the past ten years, I have gone from a patriot to an anti-nationalist. Nationalism is not some advanced thought to begin with, nor is it a simple natural feeling; it is something that emerged only in the past two or three hundred years. It is a purely brainwashed thing. Now the party-state grabs this straw to increase its own legitimacy and stir up nationalist sentiment. For someone like me, out of step with mainstream consciousness, honestly, I cannot help but be afraid.
III. Social Problems
1. China’s totalitarian system plus crony capitalism, now still strengthening surveillance, has completely become a police state. The country is becoming Sovietized and Iranianized. If ordinary people do not perceive it, then all the fancy empty stuff does not matter. But if you are a lucid intellectual, you know that the country and society are not developing in a good direction; that is in fact very troubling.
2. From the various signs in the trade war, it is clear that the state has been kidnapped by the privileged stratum and that the possibility of deep distributional reform has been cut off. My Party has already become an obstacle to social and economic development. But its power is too strong; it is unrealistic to judge that it will collapse soon. Even mass unemployment, I do not think, could shake it. The most likely outcome is that, like the Soviet Union, it will persist for decades or a century, a ‘Brezhnev’ era: the state strong, society stagnant. Only when the whole society has suffered under Qin for too long and builds a consensus will change be possible. That process is too long; it may be the whole life of ordinary people like us. A whole life: why not do something else? Why must one personally live through history? Would it not be better to go to a more civilized and developed place and do something that better realizes one’s value?
IV. Ideals
First, to emigrate and settle in at the beginning, I still have to rely on skilled migration. That is, following the current path: data analysis / mining -> machine learning / artificial intelligence.
After settling in, depending on the pressure of life, if the pressure is not great I may go back to school and study the historical / social questions I have always been interested in.
Brother, when you were young you thought of defending the country and protecting the home, while my ideal when young was to be a Napoleon, throw myself into revolution, spread advanced ideas, and improve society.
Now all of that looks like a joke. But human nature and basic value orientation do not change. This is also why I cannot return to the system: it may be that all your lifetime of hard work only makes this society worse. That I cannot endure.
If I decide to emigrate, then I am basically declaring that I completely abandon my ambitions in social activity and my pursuits in a career (I never had them anyway, so it does not matter whether I abandon them), and turn instead to the simple pursuit of intellectual growth.
Emigrating is also a learning process of opening one’s eyes to the world: to actually live within it and study how developed societies operate. That is something mere tourism and amusement cannot show you.
V. The Macro Situation
The trade war, in my view, cannot be won.
The disparity in strength is vast, and those who lack the Way have little help; this is not something national pride can solve.
In the next few years the effects will appear: industrial relocation, workers unemployed. The current emperor is no more than a middle-school Red Guard; his insight and skill are crushed by Trump. I simply cannot see what will be used to respond when the time comes; I only hope there will be capable people then.
And even if the domestic economy continues to boom, and in a few years my assets are crushed by those of my peers in China, so that I miss out just like those who went abroad twenty years ago, I no longer think it is something I will regret in the future. I have become indifferent to these things. I now think that maintaining a generally respectable material life is enough. Following my nature, broadening my experience, and doing what I am passionate about is far more meaningful than these numerical symbols.
VI. Personal Life
Depending on circumstances, I may have a few more children.
VII. Questions Still Uncertain
1. The difficulty of finding a job. I am already mentally prepared to try again next year if it does not work out the first time.
2. Racial discrimination. I have long been tested by this thing called discrimination. In Beijing and Shanghai I still had to be discriminated against by locals. Even if the nature is different, I do not think it can be worse than the institutional discrimination here in China.
3. Integration. I will let it take its course and not force it. The main thing is still up to oneself: whether after leaving the motherland one can continue to grow and improve spiritually.
4. The refugee / Islamic question.
The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Next: Joys of a Floating LifeIf this stayed with you, write to me
The FeiThink Library
First published 2019.05.21