The FeiThink Library · Standalone

On a C9 Alumni Gathering

9 min

Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.

Last Sunday in Amsterdam I attended an alumni gathering of about a hundred people from Tsinghua, Peking, Fudan, Shanghai Jiao Tong, Zhejiang and Tongji.

I have to say I spent the whole time thoroughly uncomfortable.

When I got back I meant to write something and let rip. But a few days have passed, and now I would rather work out why.

1. The Absence of Courtesy

Having spent long enough with European friends, I have been learning European manners by osmosis.

One simple rule: even with someone you do not know, you smile and make eye contact.

From beginning to end I got almost no response.

At first I sat down at a table near the door and talked with a few people there. Then four more arrived; they greeted only the people they knew, sat straight down, and buried themselves in their phones, avoiding any exchange with me, a stranger.

The atmosphere froze me up entirely, and I found it pointless. So I picked up my coat, got up to use the toilet, and came back to look for a seat further in.

Passing a table with two empty seats, I asked whether it was full. The person opposite said curtly that it was. No please, no sorry, no softening of any kind. I nodded and moved on at the time, but the more I thought about it the angrier I got: rude, plain rude. Could you not have fetched another chair? You just brush off a stranger like that.

I ended up at a table furthest in, only half full. The atmosphere was much the same: no one particularly welcomed you. If you said nothing, people would raise their eyelids and go back to their phones. So I had to turn myself into an E and start greeting people. The newcomers were the same: they greeted only those they knew. Only when I spoke to one of them did she pause for a moment, see that I was no acquaintance, and give a quick response.

One attitude stood out: if they do not know you, they may treat you as air, as if you did not exist.

Everyone used to be like this, so I took it for granted. Now I think it is quite remarkably rude.

I was like this too when I first came to Europe. Only when I really looked in the mirror did I discover how unbearable I had been.

In the past I dug in and pleaded that you Europeans did not understand Chinese customs: for us Chinese, avoiding eye contact is the respectful thing, and looking someone straight in the eye is the rude thing. In the old days, if you dared look the emperor in the eye, you lost your head.

Now that the boomerang has come back to me, I see there was never any excuse.

European humanism and the spirit of equality run through every corner of daily life.

The Chinese habit is to exalt the other and abase oneself in order to show respect, without realizing that this way of ranking people high and low is itself a backward philosophy: it holds that a person’s dignity and worth depend on social position and external conditions, not on something innate.

Too many people are in the habit of seeing human relations as a zero-sum game in which one rises as the other falls, but that is finally a crude way of looking at the world. At the last English Corner reunion I talked with Panda and the others about love that asks for nothing. He said he was not yet capable of loving without expecting anything back. It really does take an overhaul of an entire worldview and set of values.

We respect others not in order to receive respect in return, but to honor in them the part they share with us, the part that makes them human and cannot be reduced or stripped away by their utility: their dignity. A person should never be treated merely as an object or a pure instrument.

Nor do we care for others without asking anything in return in order to get a transactional return; we are caring for our own reflection in them. In practicing this love that asks for nothing we seek no practical or material gain, and yet its reward far exceeds anything material: a fullness of spirit, the heart’s sense of being planted on solid ground, our belonging as one member of humanity as a whole.

2. The Barrenness of the Conversation

Over the whole evening I leaned in to eavesdrop on several groups. The talk was work, or renovation, or else how to keep a foothold on both sides, swapping notes on how to look after one’s own interests with finesse.

I honestly found it suffocating to listen to. You are all graduates of China’s finest universities; is this all you can talk about when you get together?

Beyond the immediate grind, is there no ideal, no distance? What about your interests? Your enthusiasms? The part of you that is uniquely human?

I had skipped a reading group that clashed in time, precisely because I could not stand the nonsense of long discussions of Chinese medicine there, and came to see whether C9 students might have different things to talk about. I had imagined that a roomful of clever people could talk about anything under the sun, but all I heard was odds and ends, chicken feathers and garlic skins.

Two days after getting back, the night before last, it struck me: is this not exactly the atmosphere of student societies in my university days? The familiar Chinese package, transplanted intact. I disliked this sort of thing as an undergraduate, and now that I am older I have even less intention of accommodating it.

Then I thought again: when Europeans get together, most of the time there is not much in the way of deep conversation either.

So where does this whole-body discomfort of mine actually come from?

I thought it over, and it comes down to three things:

First, a different sense of hierarchy. Among Chinese, you feel you are first pressed to the ground; unless you display a prowess that makes people look at you twice, unless you become a big name, a boss, you earn only a little respect. A stranger, an ordinary person, is simply treated as air. Among Westerners the atmosphere is more equal: your dignity is not diminished, you are not counted as nothing.

Second, a highly uniform utilitarian set of values. Everyone seemed to be cautiously plotting his life, terrified of a misstep. In the Netherlands they worry about missing the high salaries and the chances to get rich back home; they exchange workplace experience tirelessly; the older ones play the senior handing down the wisdom of one who has been through it, the younger ones cautiously ask for career and development advice. There is nothing exactly wrong with this. An alumni gathering, what did you expect? But to my ear it was all the sound of coins being counted.

Third, cliques closing ranks, the atmosphere of acquaintance-only sociability. They greet and talk only with people they know and treat everyone else as air. In a group discussion, if they do not know you, they simply ignore your question. Thoroughly unpleasant.

I thought of an Irishman in Seville who struck up a conversation with me. After a couple of sentences I stopped answering him, while Cristina, a Spanish woman traveling with me, talked with him much longer. Afterwards Cristina told me off: she always tries to keep a conversation with someone from falling to the ground. I used to plead my INTJ temperament and say I dislike small talk (small talk). Now I finally understand what small talk is for: it is respect and care for the other person, sparing them the feeling of being overlooked and shut out.

3. Two Interludes

At the first table there was a Fudan senior who had been in the Netherlands twenty years. He asked why I had run, whether it was the work pressure back home. I said it was politics. He said politics has no effect on an ordinary person’s life. That one sentence choked me, and my old habit of arrogance surged up: I said, right, ordinary people. (Meaning that I am not one of them.)

Tell me, if an American said he had emigrated to Europe because Trump came to power (and I have indeed met quite a few), would you add, what does that have to do with you, an ordinary person? Why is it that I, a Chinese, may not emigrate for political reasons? Because I was born Chinese, must I hide my head and scrape a living? May I not have ideals and aspirations for the society I live in? To choose freely how to live is a right everyone should have; why does it become here a privilege that ordinary people do not deserve? I care about politics and study philosophy in the hope of finding a way out, so that ordinary people too need not all live like ants.

Later an alumnus from Peking University shared a statistic: Chinese in the Netherlands contribute about as much in welfare as they draw, and draw slightly more. Someone then accounted for it by saying that Chinese students here receive housing benefit. Some people put on a show of outrage, as though students drawing housing benefit disgraced the Chinese and damaged their standing as model citizens. I wanted to say: do you not pay taxes and contribute to welfare precisely in order to help those who need help? And these are your own compatriots, students still in school with no income, not people who do nothing at all and live off benefits. They simply cannot bear to see anyone get a little ‘advantage’. And these are people who have lived in Europe for ten or twenty years. The foreign suit may be on the body, but the heart is still a Chinese chip: not a drop of the European humanist spirit absorbed, not the least awareness of giving something back to society.

4. Looking in the Mirror

Recently I had been meaning to ask my European friends what bad habits I needed to correct.

One alumni gathering basically laid out the answer in concrete form.

To mirror others is to mirror oneself; in criticizing others I am criticizing myself. I recognized in my past self the bad habit of disrespecting people.

On the way home I made a private resolution:

Floor the accelerator, speed up the exit from Asia into Europe, and do not look back.


A Supplementary Note

As I wrote in Yi Ziyou wei Chi de Ai he E (Love and Evil Measured by Freedom), I hold a deep love for my native land, and have poured far more of my heart into it than those who merely talk about patriotism.

Because of that deep love, I want every Chinese to be able to live a life with dignity.

Yet this cultural soil of hierarchical differential order is obstructing this ultimate end.

So I criticize this culture without mercy, hoping to thoroughly destroy this outdated philosophy of life and replace it with new thinking.

Please take note.

Yi Ziyou wei Chi de Ai he E

https://mdnice.com/writing/bb27e34c244a4e2cb86fd631e6ee84f8

The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Next: Musashi, Go Farm

If this stayed with you, write to me

New volumes arrive here

Email RSS

On a C9 Alumni Gathering
The FeiThink Library
First published 2026.03.06

Fei Huang · Writes from Amsterdam on Kant, Dostoevsky, and the moral life.