The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Feminism

8 min

Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.

Over the past few days I read Li Yinhe’s Feminism straight through.

Compared with Ueno Chizuko in Misogyny, who observes the world from a sage’s perspective and, through examples, lets you feel the author’s thought,

Li Yinhe’s Feminism is instead a map for understanding feminist thought, conveniently helping you sort out the lines.

It really suits my reading habits. (Thanks, Momo

Feminism has many schools, and the core disagreement is the struggle over the status of men and women.

Male superiority, female inferiority: patriarchy

Female superiority, male inferiority: radical feminism / cultural feminism

Equality between men and women: liberalism / socialism

Blurring gender: postmodernism

Below I will set the book aside and talk about my own understanding.

1. Patriarchy

Under patriarchy men are victims too: on one hand they discriminate against women, on the other they cannot avoid confronting women.

Looking back, when we were young we were shaped by social culture into sexists (both men and women), seeing the other sex as a different species.

Yet we could not avoid learning to deal with the opposite sex.

People who see each other as different species cannot have a smooth first contact.

For example, I have seen very macho men, or men with a virgin complex, approach women almost with a Madonna complex before they have really had contact with them, naive to the point of being laughable (if not cute).

But whether it is the Madonna or the whore, both objectify others; the image projected in your head is very far from the other person’s real self, so a woman cannot help wondering whom exactly you are dating, let alone expecting you to attend to women’s complex and delicate feelings. It is hard not to stumble this way.

If one can be treated gently, there is still a chance to keep learning; if one meets the wrong person or is always rejected, that can breed more extreme choices: misogyny (or misandry), PUA, and the like.

Those who can quickly discard preconceptions and really try to understand the other person get along more smoothly with the opposite sex;

while those with stubborn views suffer more, and some never learn in their whole lives, remaining victims of their own views for life.

Looking back now, it feels quite unnecessary to create gender segregation artificially in this way.

If social culture could plant the seeds of equality and mutual understanding from the start, why would everyone have to take a lesson in repudiating the past?

2. Radical Feminism

Radical feminism treats men as the enemy and advocates abolishing male supremacy.

My attitude is: intellectually I do not support it, politically I do not oppose it.

Intellectually I cannot see its loftiness. Even if I understand its starting point, I feel its intellectual core is racialist, overemphasizing what is innate, and it treats men as the enemy, aiming at particular people rather than at social and cultural institutions.

Politically I have no reason to oppose it. What reason is there to oppose the resistance of the oppressed?

People casually talk about ‘extremist feminism.’ My feeling is the opposite: it is not extreme enough.

It is just some cursing. How is that extreme?

Look at the history of Western feminist movements: those were far more radical.

If we do not limit ourselves to feminist movements, we can also look at workers’ movements in modern history: there was hardly so much civilized protest.

Gandhi, with nonviolent noncooperation, is honored as a Mahatma because that was rare. And his opponent was the British, who at least had some decency.

The Black civil rights movement was not only Martin Luther King, who advocated peaceful struggle; there was also an important figure, Malcolm X (the model for Magneto in X-Men), who was also a fellow with plenty of martial virtue.

3. Cultural Feminism

Cultural feminism holds that feminine traits are the highest value of human behavior and emphasizes a separate women’s culture.

I actually agree a little. I also think the world might be better if women ruled it. Look at the performance of the female prime ministers of Finland and New Zealand: the whole business of social governance feels more humane, and happiness indices are high.

But the problem is that the world has not achieved perpetual peace, and there is still no unified representative world government; the order of the whole world is ultimately built on violence. And this is still generally considered the home ground of masculine traits.

4. Liberalism

My basic position is liberal.

Recognize differences on the basis of equality of persons.

On one hand because it is fair; on the other because it is realistically feasible.

Looking at the current state of gender equality in the Nordic countries, it is not perfect but basically satisfactory, and it can keep improving.

So I think this school is the most realistically feasible.

Only for some premodern countries, the road from barbarism to civilization is still long.

Of course, the Nordic countries are not fundamentalist liberalism either; there is a socialist element. To be precise, social democracy.

In fact, I feel that apart from China, there is nowhere else where so many people still believe in fundamentalist liberalism.

Liberalism, as I see it, is the effort to build a world of equal opportunity, so that gender, race, ethnicity, class and other innate things do not become limits on people.

For example, women are born paying a menstrual tax: for a large part of their lives they bear the expense of sanitary products, and there are also the effects of childbirth on career development, while the benefits of childbirth are shared by society. It is obviously unfair for one party alone to bear all the costs while others share the benefits.

From my position, legislation should then level the differences in opportunity between the two sides and let everyone compete on a fair starting line.

4. Postmodernism

Postmodernism reaches the level of epistemology: it questions the certainty and stability of all existing knowledge and order.

It opposes the gender binary, opposes the concept of gender itself, and opposes the idea that gender is innately unchangeable.

No wonder I have heard skeptical arguments from women more than once; so this is postmodernism.

Ah, that was my ignorance.

I have not yet studied postmodernism systematically. Toward this kind of skeptical theory I currently remain reserved; I do not think that being trendy makes it impressive.

If you argue from skepticism, your own theory must also withstand skeptical testing.

And although skepticism is a sharp weapon against power, reality also requires us to construct.

Reading the whole book, I feel feminism still cannot be a system of its own.

It is basically the application of other philosophical theories, or slogans of political movements.

5. Black Feminism

There are other minor currents that are also illuminating.

For example, Black feminism holds that being Black is harder than being a woman.

They feel that the issues previous feminisms focused on were all problems faced by middle-class white women in the West. As Black women, they must first be loyal to their Black compatriots.

This reminds us of one point: besides gender, there are many other factors in this world: class, race, ethnicity, region, urban versus rural…

As in China, urban women enjoy more rights than rural men, for example the urban-rural income gap (2.5:1), access to education (63% of rural children have not attended high school), social security (a pension of 105 yuan per month), political rights (before 2010, four rural votes equaled one urban vote), and so on.

I have a vague, unproven feeling: if gender is the number one trouble in your life, that actually shows from the side that you already enjoy many rights others do not have.

Perhaps others, before the difficulty of being a woman, have other and greater difficulties;

and the number one problem for you may rank only sixth for someone else.

I do not mean this pejoratively. If more and more people begin to be aware of and finally enjoy more rights, that shows our society really is progressing. The reverse is also true: if in a few years fewer and fewer people raise gender issues and everyone pays more attention to basic survival rights, that would be too sad.

If a society can bring freedom and liberation to those with all debuffs maxed out (for example, a left-behind, non-only-child, disabled woman in a remote, poor mountain village), only then does it mark true success.

6. New Feminism

What moved me most in the whole book was instead the last part, which gets little space: new feminism.

Its main feature is being very practical and not good at theory.

No strategy, only tactics; no collective, only individuals; no theory, only practice.

The book lists some very concrete things that can be done:

  • Expose the myth: the order has always been this way and will always be this way; the order is too powerful for anyone to change.

  • Work to break institutional inequality;

  • Explore the experience of other groups or individuals who are likewise discriminated against;

  • Think in parallel, putting the strong in the position of the weak;

  • Acknowledge that institutions exist, pay attention to problems, and do something to change them; encourage writing and speaking out;

  • Win support from public opinion;

  • Dare to make people uncomfortable, dare to ask questions;

  • Publicly choose to create another path;

  • Oppose racism;

  • Do not be afraid to do small things;

  • Work together with other disadvantaged groups;

  • Do not comply with other people’s standards.

Still, I find this ‘no principles’ business highly suspect: first, it is not really without principles but sets out concrete, largely uncontroversial principles of action, and the source of these ideas may well be some dead old man; second, it can slide entirely to the other extreme, the evil of having no principles. This is entirely possible: for example, criticizing male supremacy while self-righteously worshiping the strong and discriminating, or the strange species called pink feminism that I cannot understand.

But this spirit of cheerful activism still moved me (and it applies not only to feminists but equally to people with political depression):

Never mind what meaning, never mind what ism,

Doing good bit by bit is enough.

The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Next: Misogyny

If this stayed with you, write to me

New volumes arrive here

Email RSS

Feminism
The FeiThink Library
First published 2023.06.10

Fei Huang · Writes from Amsterdam on Kant, Dostoevsky, and the moral life.