The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Why Has Feminism Become Pro-Women-ism?

6 min

Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.

Is the Core of Feminism ‘Trample Men, Favor Women’?

GPT:
Real feminism is not female supremacy, nor is it ‘favoring women’. Its philosophical core is anti-universalism: it stresses the difference of subjects, the particularity of experience, the structural nature of oppression, and a suspicion of the traditional ‘neutral reason’.
Feminism’s original demand was this: to remake the concept of the ‘person’ in the social structure, so that women can be recognized as full subjects.

No wonder I have always felt out of place with feminism. It turns out the conflict lies in the core itself.

And why must I insist on the universality of morality?

Because in my view, a moral principle without universality is, at bottom, revoking the personhood of some people.

The Nazis revoked the personhood of the Jews, elitism revokes the personhood of the lower orders, and radical feminism revokes the personhood of men.

The reason the woman at the center of the Wuhan University library case provoked public outrage is precisely that she saw nothing but her own ‘gender justice’: she asserted a woman’s right not to be sexually harassed, yet felt not a trace of sympathy or remorse over cyberbullying others, harming others, destroying another person’s life. This is ‘dehumanization’ made concrete: not treating the other as a person.


Why Has Feminism in China Evolved Into the Form of ‘Trample Men, Favor Women’?

1. Gender Conflict as a Substitute Under Class Imbalance

The core contradiction in Chinese society is class rigidity and the unfair distribution of resources, but these topics are highly sensitive and cannot be discussed openly. So ‘gender’ becomes a relatively safe outlet.
Housing prices, education, health care, employment… there is nowhere to appeal the hardship, and young women project it onto ‘patriarchal oppression’; likewise, the powerlessness and marginality of lower-class men get stigmatized as ‘useless losers in the male competition’.
This is the classic ‘substitute confrontation’: the real oppressor is hidden in the structure, and the only ‘enemy’ each side can see is the other.
On the surface it is gender hatred; at bottom it is powerlessness without a voice.

I find that GPT is really far clearer-headed about social reality than many people.


2. No Philosophical Foundation, So the Theory Attaches Itself to Hostile Emotion

The spread of feminism in China lacks the skeleton of philosophical thought.
Beauvoir’s theory of the ‘other’ requires an existentialist background; Butler’s ‘gender performativity’ comes out of post-structuralism; hooks’s and Spivak’s ‘speaking from the margins’ rests on a postcolonial context.
But when these theories spread in China they are stripped of structure, of history, of philosophy, leaving only slogans and emotion.
In the end feminism is no longer the thought of ‘why oppression exists’ but the game of ‘how to manipulate discursive power’.

This matches my impression. Much ‘feminist’ talk looks entirely without principle or logic: it can merge with social Darwinism and side with the strong with perfect confidence, and it can copy the Western left’s anti-discrimination rhetoric while openly discriminating by gender and race.


3. Algorithmic Mechanisms Accelerate Polarization

Platform algorithms pursue ‘attention’ and ‘emotion’ by nature. Extreme views get recommended more than moderate thought.
Statements like ‘women should not marry or have children’ and ‘men are all garbage’ spread and get likes more easily.
This is not a victory of theory but emotional expression under algorithmic incentives.

By now different platforms have dug in, each talking to itself. A case like the Wuhan University library case, which to me involves no real dispute, gets a unanimous and completely opposite verdict on Douban.


The day before yesterday I suddenly understood why the theory of ‘group-based moral consensus’ that QY describes sounds fine yet always feels off to me. Then it struck me what her theory really means: it lets you exclude men from the moral community with a clear conscience, that is, I care only about women’s rights and interests, and men are not among my considerations.

Granted, we cannot treat everyone alike. But at the very least, the value of others in our eyes should not be negative.

In relations between people there is competition and oppression, but the larger background is cooperation and coexistence.

Whoever cannot see this and sees only hatred and hostility most likely has a leaf held up before his eyes.

Take the stigmatized guonan (the label for Chinese men): their sense of responsibility to the family stands out.

In China it is easy to see no comparison between groups and take everything as a matter of course, but look at the comparison of single-mother rates by group in the United States and it becomes obvious[^1]:

  • Black: 47% grew up in a single-parent family (Obama included)
  • Hispanic: 25%
  • White: 14%
  • Asian: lowest, 8%

The causes are of course multiple, but one reasonable conjecture is this:

The Confucian ethics once seen as ‘binding women’ were, to some degree, also protecting women from falling into a worse condition of existence.

Those traditional gender roles can be seen as a survival pact of an older age under scarce resources. Rather than pure oppression and injustice, they look more like a mutually beneficial division of labor. To reject them wholesale from a modern standpoint, and to use that rejection to encourage hatred, is unfair.


Is There an Irreconcilable Contradiction in Essence Between Feminism and Kantianism?

Their cores are indeed very different. One holds to universalism, the other rejects it.
But I think the contradiction is historical. At least the two share the humanitarian foundation of ‘humanity as an end’.

China is still a society that has not completed the transition ‘from hierarchical privilege to universal human rights’.

‘Opposing privilege’ has always been the underlying tone of my thought. And a thorough opposition: I do not want to be ‘a person above others’ myself, and I want still more that there be no ‘person above others’ in this world.

So Kant’s theory can be called both a choice of our reason and an expression of this underlying tone and will to power.

For feminism to start opposing ‘universalism’ in a society that has not completed its modern transition seems to me a historical dislocation.

The path I have in mind is still constitutionalism first, reform after: first establish a constitutional order and universal human rights, then carry out piecemeal structural reform. Of course the intellectual preparation cannot be skipped; the various currents of thought can run in parallel.

It is only that the thinking and conduct of some women are far removed from feminism’s progressiveness and justice. The backlash of public opinion provoked by the Wuhan University library case can be read as the silent majority’s response to that deviation.

I hope to see more feminists with a higher level of theory appear and give better answers to these questions.


[^1]: Pew Research Center. (2018). About one-third of U.S. children are living with an unmarried parent. Retrieved from https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2018/04/27/about-one-third-of-u-s-children-are-living-with-an-unmarried-parent

The FeiThink Library · Standalone

Next: Feminism vs Kantianism

If this stayed with you, write to me

New volumes arrive here

Email RSS

Why Has Feminism Become Pro-Women-ism?
The FeiThink Library
First published 2025.08.03

Fei Huang · Writes from Amsterdam on Kant, Dostoevsky, and the moral life.