The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Thoughts on The Mule
8 min
Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.
Last weekend I saw The Mule in the cinema, and it set off a flash flood.
A friend who watched it with me said it tells the story of the protagonist sacrificing his family for his ideal.
Irrefutable, and yet it always feels too simple.
- On the certainty of the self
Recently I have often doubted whether human nature itself can be overcome. It seems that all our efforts only make use of it; we can never fully conquer and change it.
When those stock market operators pass on their experience, they often say one must overcome the weaknesses of human nature: greed and fear. It seems their success means they have completely overcome human nature. But from my own attempts, the more likely possibility is only that when they are afraid they remind themselves to be greedy, and when they are greedy they remind themselves to be afraid, like actors switching among different masks in different roles and scenes.
Further, are people’s inclinations in fact written early into the early years of life? All later behavior is an annotation to what was decided so early. Follow it and you get joy; oppose it and you get sorrow.
People like me who have gone through the overturning and rebuilding of a worldview might argue that we still possess free will. But is it not in essence still a natural extension of nature, in some different form? For example, the specific things you pursue may already be very different from those of your early years, but from beginning to end you are seeking truth and happiness.
Of course this may be excessively sophistical, very much like what Wang Xizhi called the delusion that life and death are one and the fabrication that Pengzu and the short-lived are equal. For you can always raise the banner that everyone pursues happiness (pursuit of happiness) and flatten the differences between people.
But the point I want to make is this: are the more specific forms by which you reach happiness also already written early? What are the conditions of your happiness, what weight and priority do your various needs have?
Admitting this is certainly pessimistic about human agency, but it is meaningful for individual happiness. To recognize one’s real needs early, the so-called ‘know thyself’, the so-called ‘who you are’, may perhaps avoid some unnecessary tragedies.
So, if I had to choose between the two, I do not think the protagonist’s bleak old age is such a foolish thing. It follows from his nature. At the same time I think the protagonist is tragic, and the cause of the tragedy is that he did not recognize early enough how important family was to him, or rather that he did not learn early enough to express his love for his family. If he could have realized it earlier, perhaps a better and happier balance could have been reached.
- The meaning of sacrifice
On sacrifice:
1. For two people or more, I believe no one should sacrifice, and no one has the obligation or the right to sacrifice for others.
(1) For parents and children, lovers, and friends: is the person you sacrifice for willing to have you sacrifice for them? Is there really no other way but sacrifice? If you regret it later, whom will you blame?
I have truly seen too much emotional blackmail. The ideal way for family and friends to be with one another is mutual understanding, mutual support, mutual fulfillment. With you, I have become a better version of myself.
(2) For a group/community/nation: for whom exactly are you sacrificing? What if your sacrifice only breaks the rules and shakes qualities more valuable for the healthy development of the community? What if your sacrifice only makes it easier for bad people to do evil?
Those who want to devote themselves to a group, a nation, or a people, if it is merely out of personal feeling, are beyond reproach, but by no means should they glorify themselves and place themselves on the moral high ground. Whether you love or not is a personal choice. I have already seen too much stupidity, ignorance, and narrowness.
2. For the individual, I think sacrifice based on individual will is necessary.
I saw from Fan a quotation that someone or other falsely attributed to Max Weber (I read the whole of The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism and never found it):
‘The only way to save the soul is asceticism, sacrifice, and an unwavering commitment to simplicity and plainness.’
I deeply agree. Absolute selfishness also seems not to accord with human nature.
3. As for personal goals, goals that exist at the same time and conflict with one another are indeed hard to reconcile.
This is an almost eternal contradiction. Even if you were Thanos, able to wipe out half of all living beings with a snap of your fingers, you would still have no way to reconcile the grand plan of population control with the person you love most.
This is also what stirs the emotions and makes one feel deeply powerless.
- The importance of human relationships
When I saw Eastwood in The Mule, I saw my aging self.
All along the way I have gone my own way.
Unlike others, who always have a life template that suits them and can have friends they have played with since childhood, I am constantly waving goodbye to people, mostly without even a proper ceremony; one turn of the back and it is a lifetime.
Looking back, my best states have always been when I was with friends, whether sitting at the same desk with Niezi in high school or in the recent German class. Friends are the catalyst for my inspiration and talent. Without friends, I am only an ordinary person who occasionally dazzles.
Love is equally indispensable. When my mother came to Shanghai in April, her first sentence before she was fully awake in the morning was ‘Son, believe me…’ What she meant was that I could trust her to protect me so that I need not emigrate. The same sort of thing happened when Mark woke up in a Chongqing hotel; his first sentence was to suggest that I cut off all contact with my ex. You know you are cared and loved. Those who are loved are blessed; there is nothing better than this.
- Conclusion
Once these things are understood, there is no need for further doubt.
1. On ideals
You are what you are; no matter what, you cannot force yourself to settle for what you dislike.
If you distort your nature and force yourself, that is the sort of tragedy I have already seen too much of.
What you want to pursue, pursue bravely.
And what I most want to do now is travel through the vast journey of the world. Seek Truth.
2. On human relationships
The core is family, family.
Family by blood, lover, brothers & sisters by choice. The criterion distinguishing them from friends is love. With family, never abandon and never give up; strive for understanding and support.
After that are friends, friends.
Partner, consultant … The criterion distinguishing them from an acquaintance, a connection, is interest & trust. Treat friends with sincerity and fairness; put friends above time and money.
The test for lacking interest is arbitrary refusal.
The test for lacking trust is actual malice (Actual Malice).
Those who satisfy both tests can be kicked out of the circle of friends without hesitation or guilt.
The three lines above sound offhand, but in fact they troubled me for many days. Recently I have just cut ties in my heart with a friend I have known for nearly ten years.
I now think that treating separation lightly is the attitude one should hold.
people come, people go. People come and go; this is the most normal thing in the world.
Lasting forever depends too much on fate. An accidental and brief companionship is already precious enough.
3. On sacrifice and regret
I once read about three objective functions for life decisions.
The global optimum, given human bounded rationality and limited information, is something beyond reach.
The current optimum easily magnifies what is before one’s eyes without limit.
Minimum regret is probably the most practicable guiding advice for ordinary people.
Before any major decision, ask yourself only, ‘Will I regret this in the future?’
If after repeated consideration you cannot avoid a foreseeable bad outcome, then unless you are a heaven-sent genius with a stroke of inspiration, swallow your broken teeth along with the blood.
4. On happiness
Recently someone asked me, ‘Do you have a bottom line?’ After thinking it over, my answer is: ‘Stupidity.’
But I find that this thing also rises with the tide. The threshold of tolerance for others keeps being raised higher and higher.
But if you really are that clever and the result is only that you become an angry boy, farther from happiness and truth, then that itself is a very stupid thing.
If you detest patriots and flag-bearers, just don’t watch; if you hear obviously brainless words, just don’t listen and don’t argue.
When you see others chasing an illusion, where do you get the confidence that what you pursue is the only reality? Even if it really is an illusion, what if it is someone else’s lifeline?
Walking through the world, I keep two maxims in mind:
One is ‘Nothing is a big deal,’ the other is ‘If it doesn’t work, fuck it.’
Note:
On Writing
I feel that the noise in my head has increased again when I write.
When I write, I consider how it will feel to others after they read it, whether I am too pseudoscientific, whether I will make a fool of myself, whether after finishing I will lose a few more of my already few friends.
But fuck that.
The purpose of opening this account is exactly to say things that deviate from convention, things sentimental and pretentious, things shocking, to curse and rail at heaven and earth as I please, to speak freely. If I still have to worry so much, I might as well abandon it. (I really am considering setting up another private blog in the cloud, since there is censorship here too.)
Another bad tendency in my writing is wanting to say everything I have thought and felt recently, so the piece ends up with no main line. Bad, bad. From now on I will speak one point at a time, do less long-winded exposition, write more short pieces; one point at a time is enough.
The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Next: A Few Modest Thoughts on the Social SciencesIf this stayed with you, write to me
The FeiThink Library
First published 2019.09.26