The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Summary of Session 0 of the Robert's Rules Reading Club
13 min
Machine translation from the Chinese original, not reviewed by the author.
On Friday night this week I organized Session 0 of the Robert’s Rules Reading Club, as a rehearsal before it becomes a formal long-term activity.
The first half went off the rails; the second half was lively. Overall I give myself 7.5 points.
I. General Course of the Event
1. Free-speaking segment,
The host briefly introduced the general flow of the event.
Everyone took turns speaking freely around the Enlightenment.
The first speaker was underprepared; the second, third, and fourth all talked about the Enlightenment in terms of abstract concepts.
Among them, Teacher Yao’s remarks were the most engaging, discussing the Enlightenment quite professionally from the angle of historical concepts.
The earlier remarks were too abstract, so the host broke in and suggested people talk more about their own experiences.
Zizhan and Picha Ge spoke early; I did not quite follow them.
Then we went in order, and two women spoke about the Enlightenment from their own experience.
After one round of speaking, there was still no controversial topic with enough resonance.
People said that the idea of the Enlightenment remained vague to them and lacked a clear definition.
The host cited Kant’s view in What Is Enlightenment?:
Dare to know.
Dare to know, dare to use your own reason, dare to question what is unreasonable, dare to choose for yourself with reason.
This won majority agreement.
We entered the acceleration round, with each person asked to propose a topic they considered controversial.
In the process, because Picha Ge insisted on the idea of guoxue (traditional Chinese learning) and on a laissez-faire, wuwei (non-action) view of enlightenment and education, the host called a vote; more than two thirds opposed discussing the topic, so it was dropped.
Because Picha Ge tried to interrupt someone else’s speech, he received the first yellow card of the session and performed a split for everyone.
One woman, drawing on a real confusion in her life, ended the free-speaking segment with the topic ‘Should children be educated according to school textbooks?’, and we moved into the first debate.
Problems at this stage:
1) Because I worried that too many rules would burden everyone, the host did not explain all the rules at once at the beginning. I wanted to introduce the rules by explaining them as problems came up, so that people would find them easier to understand and accept.
The result was that the role design concerning the police was never used before the event ended.
Yet this part is important. If it had been explained and introduced in advance, it could have effectively reduced the host’s burden.
It would have reduced the host’s later state of flailing, dazedness, and loss of control.
It could also have produced more rulings and made the event more interesting.
2) Problems with topic setting
In the middle of the event the host tried several times to set a topic, without success.
In the introductory material before the event, a topic had been mentioned: ‘whether Zhong X is doing product endorsements.’
Teacher Yao had prepared thoroughly on this topic and volunteered that he hoped to discuss it.
Before discussion there was a vote, and the overwhelming majority opposed it, so the topic was scrapped.
This point is in fact a flaw in the rules for topic setting.
The vote before discussing a topic should be a vote on ‘whether to discuss the topic,’ not a survey of views on the topic.
That is, even if I hold an opposing view on the topic, if I am interested in the topic, hope to discuss it, and hope to hear different opinions, then I should vote yes.
Only when more than two thirds oppose discussing the topic should it not be discussed.
This both protects the minority’s right to speak and avoids wasting the majority’s time.
2. First Debate
Topic: Should children be educated according to school textbooks, or should we insist on teaching them what we ourselves believe is correct?
Because the negative side had more people, we used a ‘mock debate’ format.
Everyone was randomly given red or blue number cards. According to the assigned identity and order, affirmative and negative spoke in turn: Blue 1, Red 1, Blue 2, Red 2, and so on.
Originally, under Robert’s Rules, each person should have had 2 chances to speak. But the host was already dazed, and to make counting easier ruled that each person had only 1 chance.
After everyone had spoken, those who raised their hands in the middle and asked to speak were given extra chances to speak.
The final vote showed a majority in favor of the view that most teaching should follow school textbooks.
After the debate, although I asked the woman who had raised the topic whether she felt the discussion had clarified things, and she very nicely replied that it had, I did not feel that it had.
People simply stated opinions according to the identity they had been given; no one really threw themselves into defending their own camp.
Then people began to argue about ‘whether there should be mock debate.’ The host had a flash of inspiration and set ‘Should we have mock debate or real debate?’ as the topic for debate, and we entered the lively second half.
Problems at this stage:
- Although the second vote showed a majority in favor of ‘including a mock debate segment,’ mock debate really is not very conducive to creating a debate atmosphere.
In future activities we should still try as much as possible to do real debate. Let people speak from genuine feeling, and encourage them to express their real views.
The purpose of including a mock debate segment is to get people to practice perspective-taking, to examine a question from the standpoint of different positions.
What I now think are situations suited to mock debate are:
a. When the debate atmosphere is too heated and both sides cling to their views and refuse to yield, switch sides;
b. When the numbers on each side are too unequal, have some undecided participants act as the minority, to create balance.
A better way is to adjust the topic to balance the numbers.
- Problems with topic setting
Setting topics is a skill: topics can be split, adjusted, and learned by anyone.
The topic we began with was ‘Should we teach according to school textbooks, or should we insist on teaching what one believes is correct?’
The initial vote had more on the negative side than the affirmative: most thought we should insist on teaching what one believes is correct. But when the vote was taken, the host quietly substituted the topic by adding ‘most’: whether one thought most teaching should follow school textbooks.
First, this should not have happened: the host should not change the topic on his own.
But the vote result became an overwhelming majority in favor of ‘most teaching should follow school textbooks.’
What this suggested to me is that an unbalanced topic can also be balanced by splitting it along degrees.
For example, the ‘Zhong X topic’ that was rejected at the start could be adjusted in the following ways:
Do you think he is doing product endorsements? (In fact: very few in favor)
Do you think his merits outweigh his faults, or his faults outweigh his merits? (In fact: the negative side is still very small)
Do you think a seven-to-three split of merit to fault is a broadly reasonable assessment? (Guess: possibly relatively balanced)
Do you think he is a flawless moral model? (Guess: the opposing side might then have the advantage)
3. Second Debate
Topic: Should there be mock debate?
After the not entirely successful groundwork of the first debate, a live example from the room finally gave everyone a concrete, intuitive case and topic that they all had something to say about.
The host was finally freed from the flailing, dazed state.
The discussion was lively, back and forth, and everyone exchanged views fully.
After the debate, the host held a vote on the action decision ‘whether to include a mock debate segment’: if the no votes outnumbered the yes votes, the reading club would from then on do only real debate.
The result was 6 in favor and 4 against (abstentions not counted), passing the decision to ‘include a mock debate segment.’
During this, Teacher Yao, because he did not state his position before speaking, received the second yellow card of the session and sang a line of the national anthem for us in a stirring voice.
Teacher Yao protested, saying that adding this sort of game segment was boring.
So we held a village assembly and voted on ‘whether to include a Truth or Dare type game design’; the result passed by an absolute majority.
In the last 5 minutes, people in the back rows were invited to give their reflections.
Lin Songmao rated it highly, saying ‘this was the best reading club she had ever attended’; this old man was greatly comforted.
Mei Ya, in the less enthusiastic camp, thought the host should have thought the topics through more carefully in advance.
II. Common Questions
Do we need an ‘all-powerful’ host?
I disagree.
This is a common challenge to one’s competence when organizing activities.
At this event, because the host was nervous at the opening, a woman left not long after it began.
My question is:
Why do people place expectations on the host beyond the function of ‘maintaining order’?
1. Is topic setting something that must be done by the host?
Although the topic that saved the second half today did come from a flash of inspiration on my part,
why must the role of having a flash of inspiration be the host’s?
Why couldn’t it be anyone present, whether prepared in advance or struck by a sudden idea?
In my conception, each person can at some point partly lead the room, Take charge.
Everyone can be the host.
The same goes for so-called ‘control of the room.’
2. Is it the host’s responsibility to draw topics out of people’s remarks and design them?
To express one’s own view clearly falls within each person’s own sphere of responsibility.
If one disagrees with someone else, one should also clearly express the point of disagreement oneself.
This is something each person should work to learn and master; the responsibility lies entirely with each individual.
Granted, an excellent host can do a great deal to make up for others’ shortcomings, help complete their views, and help them express themselves fully.
But you should understand that at such moments the host is in fact taking on an extra portion of responsibility that was not originally his.
Back to the question above:
Why do people feel they need an all-powerful host?
To my mind this comes from a subconscious longing for the “superman” and for “big government”: a longing for someone else to make your decisions for you, to step forward and settle every troublesome thing for you.
No one teaches you how to think for yourself, how to voice an opinion bravely;
no one teaches you how to deal with people as an equal, how to reach consensus and build order with others through equal self-governance.
All anyone teaches you is to “obey”.
When a husband and wife quarrel, do they feel they need a moderator?
Do they need someone to set the agenda for them? To work the room and adjust the mood?
So why different? What makes it different?
III. Overall Summary
What went reasonably well
1. Introducing the idea of “equal self-governance”
Everyone’s right to speak and right to vote was exactly equal.
Teacher Yao, who had read more books than anyone in the room, had exactly the same speaking time and the same chances to speak as everyone else.
Rules like “there must be a sham debate” or “there must be a game segment” were all voted through one person, one vote. It was clear that the rules were not decided by me forcing them through alone.
2. Holding to the rule of “alternating sides”
What was carried out comparatively well this time was the rule of “alternating sides”: pro and con speak in turn, and those who have not yet spoken go first.
Compared with speaking in order of seating, this gives a higher density of information exchange and more easily produces a lively atmosphere.
This should be kept in future sessions.
What went badly
1. Many other rules were not well enforced.
For instance, in the matter of grabbing the microphone, only Picha Ge was penalized.
Others in between also grabbed the floor without raising a hand.
I used to think that raising a hand to speak was too formal for this rule, that there was no need for such formality.
But later, when everyone was cooperating well, raising a hand did not feel so out of place after all.
Then there was the rule about stating your position first: again only Teacher Yao was penalized.
Later everyone did the same, because the host would call out pro and con each time, so people skipped this step and went straight into argument without stating a position.
This time the host did not have enough police power and could not penalize everyone one by one.
Next time I will try to be a salted fish (xianyu, an idler), calling out nothing and leaving it all to the police.
2. Some friends said they came for the games, and by the end still had not found where the police were
Ahem, well…
I thought up a lot of content before the event, and much of it went unused;
and some things I never thought of beforehand turned out unexpectedly well.
Improve in the course of action.
One more word, to avoid misunderstanding:
what most needs improving is not individual ability but the way the group organizes itself.
IV. Plans for the Future
1. Separation of powers
Starting from the next session, the host’s powers and duties will be split up.
Strip the roles of judge and police away from the host.
Set up a separate judge, given to someone who does not want to take part in the pro and con debate, to serve as a neutral third party ruling on violations of the rules.
The judge is a passive role: if no one brings a charge, the judge does not pursue it. The judge only rules and issues yellow cards, and bears no responsibility for pointing out violations; that is separated from the police role.
Create the police role, divided into “task forces” and Chaoyang qunzhong (the Chaoyang masses, i.e. neighborhood informants).
Task forces:
fix the rules and divide them among several people, each person watching one item.
1. Personal attack task force
2. Microphone grabbing task force
3. Position first task force
4. Off-topic task force
5. Timing and counting task force
Chaoyang qunzhong:
everyone can spontaneously take part in monitoring and report behavior that breaks the rules.
After an officer reports a violation, it goes to the judge to decide, and the judge issues a yellow card to the person who broke the rule.
After a successful report, the officer earns a green card as a reward.
A green card can cancel out one yellow card of one’s own; it also carries the right of priority in punishment, priority in punishing those who break the rules.
The punishment: truth or dare.
2. Case first
Start from a case and lead into the topic. It resonates more easily.
The first half of this session was in fact a case laying the ground for the second half.
Talking abstractly about metaphysics straight off sets the bar too high.
3. Frequency
Organizing this thing takes too much out of you.
The preliminary plan is one big debate every two weeks.
In between, hold loose, informal tea gatherings: drink tea, shoot the breeze, talk about the books, films and shows you have seen lately, the big and small things you care about… free rambling that produces the topic for next time.
When in doubt, rules of order.
One last thing:
the essence of rules of order is not the hourglass and the gavel, those little formal toys, and not even the stiff regulations Robert laid down.
Its real spiritual principle is how to strike a balance between the individual and the collective.
The FeiThink Library · Standalone
Next: [Chicken Soup] Is the Tang monk's kasaya red or black?If this stayed with you, write to me
The FeiThink Library
First published 2020.10.25